Showing posts with label Bank Negara. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bank Negara. Show all posts

How Independent Are Central Banks Nowadays?


If you check the readership for this blog, it has downshifted markedly. I can blame the World Cup for contributing to part of the problem. But is it a problem to have lower readership? I think many may have skipped my blog as I have not talked about stocks specifically over the past 3-4 weeks. I think I am comfortable with lower readership if that is the main reason. I am not going to do things I am not comfortable just so that there are "hot things" to read in my blog. I didn't think May was a good month to be looking at stocks and neither is June, full stop. Let's reassess the situation in July. Just go and enjoy the World Cup, play some golf ... save a lot of money and headaches ... no followers, the syndicates also go to sleep anyway.

Back to the headline topic, for all the politicking and grievances with Malaysian politics, we should be thankful that Bank Negara is still "relatively" (and thats the key word) independent. We all know of a time when it was "too independent" when speculating freely in various currencies, no need to go through our history books to know when that happened.
You would never, never want your central bank to be beholden to the ruling government or as an arm of the ruling government's election machinery. Once it gets that way, you can be guaranteed a mess bigger than the initial crap you put through the system.

Bank Negara has kind of reinvented itself over the past 12-14 years, and its independence record has been much better than the rest.
Some may say that too many central bankers have been too eager to loosen monetary policies owing to the subprime mess. Granted, but do they really have a choice? Even with the Greek fiscal tragedy, there is nothing much the ECB can do other than lend Greece money.

http://i253.photobucket.com/albums/hh78/asiangirlimage/China/Zhang%20Jingchu/Zhang-Jingchu-003.jpg

If you ask a graduate economics student what the first objective of a central bank is, he/she should answer: moderate inflation while championing growth. That's it, that's the whole mantra of a central bank, no need to complicate matters.

Well, the central banks would probably have that as the main objective domestically, but they will have an overriding concern when the entire global financial infrastructure and trade are at stake. We can say that the subprime mess qualifies as such an event as credit seized up, hence the concerted Mafia like effort by all central bankers in loosening the purse strings was laudable.


When almost every central bank moved interest rates close to zero to do that, there would have been many economies which "did not need interest rates to go that low" - i.e. HK, China, Singapore and even Malaysia ~ which is why we had such an outsized jump in real estate in those economies following the subprime mess.


Zeti moved local rates back up quicker than most, and many observers failed to recognise what an important decision that was. We needed to kill off the froth. Property players may moan and groan about it, but the reality is that prices in many sub sectors of real estate has jumped out of the affordability range and into speculative bubbles. Of course ALL property developers and valuers will not agree with any thing I am saying. Just look at the top 20% of the markets in China, HK, Malaysia and Singapore ~ its the same fishes feeding the same ponds. Go to any luxury condos just completed and see how many are occupied, you'd be lucky to find a figure higher than 30%. Just go to The Loft, Suasana, the KLCC condos, and even some of the gated luxury developments. There is no push factor to force the owners to sell (yet), which is why prices are holding.

66 by ahru.

In the meantime, genuine home buyers have to go further and further out to find a place they can afford. As recent as 5 years ago, Kajang would be considered as was too far, now its considered OK. Affordability does wondrous things to the mind.
There are some developments which deserve to go higher such as the Desa Park City developments, well thought out, which is why even with higher prices, its nearly fully occupied.

But I digress, low interest rates in those markets cause higher prices and implies better affordability. There are plenty of Singaporeans, HKers and mainland Chinese who own a piece of the high end markets in Malaysia ~ and vice versa, there are plenty of players invested in the same markets. If there are no financial crisis among the group, prices can stay there till reality catches up. If there is one, then step aside from the stampede because in many of those places, many of the units/homes cannot be rented out to get a yield of 2%.

But I digress again.
There have been some instances whereby central bankers have been "influenced" to make certain decisions, and you can safely see that it brings no benefit in the end. Credibility of a central bank reflects enormously on the credibility of financial markets and the various important pillar institutions in the eyes of investors.

The South Korean government broke a decade long precedent by sending a senior finance ministry official to the meetings of Bank of Korea. Why? To ensure that interest rates are kept down.
Bank of Japan was "forced" to double a lending program for banks in March 2010 following pressure from Finance Minister Naoto Kan to do more to help the economy. The ECB has been buying sovereign bonds of affected countries in the EU to ease the pressure of higher interest rates when weaker countries in the EU needed to borrow more. The ECB should never be buying distressed debt.

The independence of a country central bank is almost sacred. Let's keep it that way.

EON Capital's Fortunes In The Coming Weeks

Business Times, SINGAPORE, Jan 5 — Doubts are surfacing over a possible merger between Hong Leong Bank and EON Bank that would create Malaysia’s fourth-largest bank with assets of RM110.5 billion.

http://photos1.blogger.com/hello/9/10888/1024/devon81152x864.jpg

In late December, Hong Leong Bank, which is controlled by the reclusive tycoon Quek Leng Chan, told the stock exchange that it had received Bank Negara Malaysia’s permission to start negotiations with “certain shareholders” of EON Capital to acquire an interest in its smaller rival.

Listed EON Capital wholly owns EON Bank. EON Capital’s largest shareholders are businessman Rin Kei Mei and Sarawak billionaire Tiong Hiew Khiing, who collectively hold 33.2 per cent of the financial firm. Other shareholders include Hong Kong-based investment fund Primus Pacific Partners (20.2 per cent), the Employees Provident Fund (12.1 per cent) and state investment agency Khazanah Nasional (10 per cent).

http://photos1.blogger.com/hello/9/10888/1024/devon41152x864.jpg

The sticking point could be price. Local news reports, citing sources, have said that Quek would be willing to pay between RM5.50 and RM6 per EON Capital share, which would value the bank at one-1.2 times book.

“A previous attempt several years ago stalled over pricing: Mr Quek is not known to pay more than what he considers fair.’

But officials familiar with Rin and Tiong said that they would expect at least RM8-8.20 a share, which would value the bank at almost 1.6 times book. There is no certainty that a deal will be struck, as this is not the first time Hong Leong Bank has eyed EON Capital. A previous attempt several years ago stalled over pricing: Quek is not known to pay more than what he considers fair.

So far, nothing has happened as Quek is said to be abroad. The Star newspaper, citing sources, said yesterday that the Employees Provident Fund and Khazanah are ‘believed’ to have exited from EON Capital. But a government official denied this.

“We haven’t received any offer so far,” he told BT.

It is also not clear where Primus would stand. Three years ago, the investment fund bought into EON Capital for a hefty RM9.55 apiece – a price Quek would probably consider astronomical. And the opposite could be said about Quek’s speculated buying price — RM5.50-6 — as far as Primus is concerned. Indeed, there is talk that Primus is approaching other funds to make a rival bid for EON Capital. According to The Star, the fund approached Singapore’s Temasek Holdings.

In theory, this makes sense. Temasek manages Malaysia’s smallest bank, Alliance, so aligning with Primus could pave the ground for an ultimate merger between EON Bank and Alliance Bank. But the Singapore investment agency has not commented publicly on The Star’s story.

What is clear is that Malaysia’s central bank would encourage a merger. Indeed, the move towards a possible merger reflects Bank Negara’s wish to winnow the Malaysian banking sector to a few large banks, to better withstand increased foreign competition starting this year. Malaysia now has eight local banks. — Business Times Singapore

http://photos1.blogger.com/hello/9/10888/1024/devon21152x864.jpg

My Take: The local media seems to be a lot more excited and certain that the deal will go through. My view is that Quek wants this deal as it seems that he will NOT be able to get the Public Bank under his wings - pricing for PBB and the size may have been the obstacles to getting PBB (please read my posting on CIMB-PBB).

http://malaysiafinance.blogspot.com/2009/12/my-prediction-for-1-biz-news-in-2010.html

Quek cannot afford not to buy another bank as that would mean some other bank getting a lot bigger when the dust settles. I do agree its a matter of pricing. If its below RM6.00 as the article above stated, I am very sure the owners would not sell. Its a sellers' market, not a buyers' market.

The angle which many have not paid sufficient attention to is the Primus block, which had a high entry price. I am certain they would have approached Temasek, which controls AFG (Alliance Bank). Please read my posting on AFG to get a grasp on their side of things.

http://malaysiafinance.blogspot.com/2009/12/whats-up-with-afg.html

Hence it is clear that Bank Negara would NOT want a sovereign wealth fund to be owning a Malaysian bank. It looks increasingly likely that DBS Bank will be asked to take over the stake, as its the only Singapore bank that still do not have a banking presence in Malaysia. Would Bank Negara frown on that? Not really as both sides are opening up.

Would Bank Negara frown on DBS Bank taking over AFG and bidding for EON Cap at the same time? I really don't think so. If indeed DBS Bank is taking over AFG, then it would also make sense to bid for EON Cap - not that they really need to. Of course DBS Bank could come in and bid for EON Cap first before swallowing AFG. I doubt very much that Temasek will be allowed to bid for EON Cap as I am certain Bank Negara do not want that to happen when they are trying to get Temasek to divest AFG.

If DBS Bank gets approval, watch EON Cap fly. Quek can wait for a better price but he cannot afford to wait till DBS Bank or some other bidder comes into the fray, and end up engaging in a price war. On balance of the above, I think Quek will try and make a deal soon, closer to RM8 and not closer to RM6.

Just my dua sen...


p/s photos: Devon Aoki

Bank Negara's Monetary Policy




    After cutting rates by 1.5% during November 2008-March 2009, Bank Negara has kept interest rates unchanged starting Q2 2009. Since cutting rates too low has its risks , the central bank has focused more on improving "credit access" in the economy. Deflationary pressures, large output gap, low resource utilization and a sluggish recovery will help the central bank to remain on hold until sometime in 2010. But deflationary pressures might ease in H2 2009 due to commodity prices and fading base effects of 2008, preventing further rate cuts.

    Will Bank Negara Remain on Hold for Now?

  • October 28, 2009: Bank Negara maintained the interest rate unchanged for the fifth consecutive month at 2.0% to support economic recovery since price pressure are still low.
  • BNM October Monetary Policy Statement: The current monetary policy is “appropriate” and will “support” economic activity as domestic economic conditions are improving with policy support, and inflation and inflation expectations are expected to remain “contained” in the coming months. BNM sees strong improvement in the labor market, domestic demand, financing activity and external trade, and these developments are expected to continue into 2010. Without any unexpected external impact, inflation in 2010 will turn positive, but remain “subdued”.
  • BNM sees limited impact of low interest rates and the risk of fueling asset bubbles. It is rather focusing on credit measures to improve liquidity in the financial system. Fiscal stimulus, past interest rate cuts and government and central bank credit measures are improving credit flow in the economy (especially for smaller firms) and slowing the pace of job losses.
  • The contraction in manufacturing activity and exports has eased since June 2009. The pace of economic contraction has eased since Q2 2009.
  • The recovery is expected to be very sluggish due to slow recovery of exports and foreign investment inflows. Excess capacity and large output gap will persist through 2009 and most of 2010. This might lead the central bank to keep interest rates on hold for a long time and be one of the last central banks in Emerging Asia to raise rates.
  • But BNM would remain vigilant about rising oil and commodity prices during the global recovery, especially as the base effects of 2008 food and oil prices start fading in Q3 2009. Going forward, improvement in private demand, lag impact of fiscal stimulus and liquidity impact of portfolio inflows might reduce deflationary pressures.
  • However, further rate cuts are not expected. Low rates pose risk of capital outflows and downward pressure on currency amid declining interest rate differential with other Asian countries and the U.S.. This is exacerbated by risks to the debt ratings. Currency has showed some gains from April 2009 since when the rates have to kept on hold.
  • Analyst Wei Zheng Kit, Citigroup: The central bank will not increase interest rates until H1 2010. BNM might be the last central bank to tighten the monetary policy in Asia.
  • Economist Vishnu Varathan, Forecast Singapore: Since economic recovery in Southeast Asian countries is weaker than India and South Korea, Malaysia will not hike interest rates earlier than these two countries.
  • Analyst Tetsuji Sano, Nomura: If global oil prices continue to increase, the government may hike domestic gasoline prices. On a year-on-year basis, the CPI will continue to remain in negative territory. The central bank is expected to keep current key rate unchanged at least until Q1 2010 as economic recovery is still "nascent". Even after the central bank begins to increase interest rate, the real interest rate will stay below zero if the CPI remains around 2.3% in 2010 and 3.3% in 2011.
  • EIU: Malaysia is in a mild and short-lived deflation owing to falling global oil and non-oil commodity prices and base effects of 2008. However, the central bank will keep interest rates at around 2% for the rest of 2009 and probably until H1 2010.
  • Morgan Stanley: Deflation will continue until the end of 2009. The central bank will start raising interest rates in H2 2010.
  • Are Deflationary Pressures in Malaysia Fading?

  • The Consumer Price Index (CPI) declined 2% y/y in September 2009 for the fourth straight month of deflation after falling 2.4% in August 2009 and 2.4% in July 2009 due to relatively lower petrol and diesel prices. Yet, the pace of deflation has been slower led by the moderation of the decline in transport and food, clothing and food wear prices. On a month-on-month basis, CPI increased to 0.3% m/m in September 2009 after rising 0.2% m/m in August 2009. (Department of Statistics Malaysia, 10/23/09)
  • Deflationary pressures are due to high base effects of Q2 2008, decline in food and oil prices relative to 2008, government subsidies for flour, sugar and bread.
  • Deflation will persist due to output gap, excess capacity in manufacturing and rising unemployment. Sluggish recovery in 2010 implies that inflation will remain low until early 2010.
  • A risk is that the base effects of 2008 will start fading by Q3 2009 and might raise inflationary pressures due to recent increase in oil and commodity prices.
  • Inflation peaked in Q3 2008 at 8.4% y/y on high food and fuel prices and electricity tariffs.
  • BNM: Inflation and inflation expectations are expected to remain “contained”. Without any unexpected external impact, inflation in 2010 will turn positive, but remain “subdued”.
  • Analyst Wei Zheng Kit, Citigroup: Deflation has bottomed in August 2009 and positive momentum will continue to increase CPI. A year-on-year CPI may enter positive territory in 2009, but the central bank will hold interest rate unchanged in October 2009.
  • Economist Intelligent Unit: Inflation will stay in slightly negative territory in H2 2009 due to the decline in global oil and non-oil commodity prices and base effects from 2008. However, lower global commodity prices are positive for growth, which could strengthen domestic demand. Inflation will pick up in 2010 as global commodity prices increase.




p/s photos: Li Xiao Lu

On Bank Negara, PPP & The Ringgit





hishamh said...

A couple of problems here. Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) is no more than an academic curiosity these days, for the simple reason that it doesn't remotely describe currency movements even between advanced economies, much less for emerging markets. So there is no firm foundation for using it as a basis for evaluating currency misalignments.

It therefore follows that analysing currency policy based on PPP values is also a red herring.

In fact, based on current theories, it's possible to argue that the causality runs the other way from your analysis - an export-oriented strategy results in low relative incomes and a depressed exchange rate, rather than a weak currency being used to support export competitiveness. Which means that the MYR exchange rate is in fact market-determined, and there is no deliberate central bank policy to weaken the currency.

3:14 PM



hisham,

You make a few good points... herein lies the 64,000 dollar question... is Bank Negara deliberately suppressing the ringgit?

Considering that the ringgit is tightly controlled, and is not totally freely exchangeable overseas, BN exerts a lot of control over the ringgit. What I mean is that no hedge fund or trade would seriously dare to bet against BN's persuasions, they would rather bet alongside with BN's persuasions. When the currency is "limited" in its free trade and its circulation, that is tantamount to controlling the currency - not that that is a bad thing. For a small open economy like ours, we cannot seriously have a totally free floating currency, how do you think our exporters and services sector going to adjust if in January the ringgit is 3.6 to the USD and in May its 4.1 but by October its 3.1.

I am more concerned in the usage of the ringgit to shape the industries we have over the longer term. Yes, short term, fighting inflation is priority number one followed by maintaining a sustainable economy. But just look at where the ringgit has been over the past 20 years. I remember it was 2.7. What that tells me is that we are deliberately attracting FDI via such a mechanism.

The ringgit should be managed, but manged to appreciate so that we can flush out those industries that should not be here. We need to move up the value curve. Ifwe have an internal target of 3.2 average for 2010, 3.0 average by 2011 and 2.8 average by 2012, believe you me, we will see some industries being taken out naturally or indrectly. The kind of FDI we attract will be different for sure. We have the resources, don't short change ourselves, don't keep adding low cost foreign workers, it makes the substantial bottom rung of the industries stay manual and low value add.Yes, its easier said than done as industries will be displaced, jobs will be lost... in other words this is exactly the structural unemployment that we need to go through. Its tough, business wise and politically, but being in positions of leadership, we must make tough decisions or else we will lock ourselves into the same sandstorm. It is very sad to see the same sunset industries still operating in Malaysia 5 or 10 years from now.

...
Oh, you want to do large scale manual soldering... go to Malaysia, there got plenty of cheap labour... Even if we keep bringing these labour intensive FDI, the best jobs that Malaysians can hope for is factory manager of a labour intensive factory looking after foreign workers. Get the ringgit to where our resources should be, and not cater and pander to the lowest common denominator.


p/s photo: Miwa Cocoa

Got A Question For Bank Negara




Dear Madam Zeti,


There is a curious trend in bank lending which I am sure you are aware of, but is troubling to me. I am sure you are aware that all property loans (or almost all property loans) given out by Malaysian banks have a 5 year lock in period. During that 5 year period if you want to refinance your loan by the same bank or take it to be refinanced to another bank, you will be whacked with a 5% penalty on outstanding amount.

Say you bought a house in 2006 for RM500,000 with a RM400,000 loan with rate of 6%. Naturally with rates coming down over the last 12 months, you should refinance the balance, but you cannot.

Is this ruling fair to property owners? Is this rule sanctioned and encouraged by Bank Negara as it obviously benefits the banks at the expense of the borrowers. Is this to stop other banks from "stealing" loans from one another? If it is, then banks SHOULD allow for refinancing inhouse with no penalty - why should borrowers not have that choice?

As the country tries to deflect a recession, interest rates come down as a monetary tool by Bank Negara. What good is the tool, what good is the lower rates if a substantial portion of the loans are "locked in", unable to take advantage of the lower rates? This neutralises the lower interest rates policies as property loans make up a huge portion of most households' balance sheet.

Why are local banks having it so good? Why can't the public be beneficiaries of better and more open competition among the banks? A borrower will go to a bank because of the service it provides. Why does that "better service" automatically goes out the door the moment you sign off on the loan? Why can't a person switch to a lower cost option two or three years down the road? If a bank loses a loan to another bank, it means the other bank can compete more effectively - i.e. lower cost of funds.

The local banks are acting like a cartel... they all agree to do this so that all can enjoy supernormal profits, lock in profits, all to the detriment of the consumer. No need to watch The Sopranos, we have the local banks.

I can understand a window of a lock in period for the banks to recoup some marketing cost, but certainly not 5% penalty.

Bank Negara should:
a) reduce the lock in period from 5 years to 2 years
b) reduce the penalty from 5% to 2%

This is one of the many big reasons why Malaysian properties are sluggish.



p/s photos: JJ

Petaling Street Hawkers Calling You Back With Deeper Discount!


Maybank had been due to complete its purchase on Friday of a 55.5% stake in BII, for US$1.5 billion. Maybank stood to lose more than 400 million ringgit if it should walk away from the deal. The regulator "changed" the rules for the deal when it come to approving the deal. The changes alter the deal strategy significantly.

I DID NOT HEAR OF SELLERS THEN OFFERING TO renegotiate the deal, or return the deposit if Maybank wanted to walk away, they held onto the terms of the deal.
Since then the share price of BII has fallen enormously. NOW THE SELLERS OFFERED to reduce the deal by 480 million ringgit. The rebate is more than the 400 million ringgit deposit Maybank stands to lose by walking away from the acquisition yesterday.

Moral of the story, how many idiots are running around in this deal? Why do the idiots think there are stupider idiots running around as well in this deal?


Bank Negara had previously blocked the acquisition after Indonesian regulators said Maybank would have to sell part of its stake in the future to comply with new rules designed to raise the shareholdings of Indonesian investors. The central bank then gave the deal the green light on September 16 after Indonesia's capital markets regulator agreed to extend the deadline for Maybank to cut its stake. In the latest move, it told Maybank that the terms needed to be revised – that is, the price reduced – because of turbulence in the global financial markets.

The concern of investors and also Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) is that Maybank would end up losing a pile if it were to pare down its stake by 20% within two years. This is because it is acquiring the shares at Rp510 while it is less than Rps330 now.

Maybank said in a statement dated Sept. 25 the Malaysian central bank ordered it to reduce the price or scrap the transaction, sparking a dispute with Indonesian authorities and a record slump in Bank Internasional's share price. Temasek said Maybank first asked for a one-month extension and a price reduction on Sept. 24, which it turned down a day later. It was informed of the objections by Bank Negara, or the central bank, on Sept. 25 at 11:32 p.m. local time, it said.

Khazanah Nasional Bhd., Malaysia's sovereign wealth fund, is paying 2.5 times the book value of PT Bank Niaga and three times book for PT Bank Lippo as it buys the remaining shares of the two Indonesian banks in a proposed merger. Khazanah and its unit, like Temasek, are either selling one of the two banks they own or merging them to meet an Indonesian central bank deadline limiting ownership to just one local bank by 2010. (Maybank's purchase price for BII was 4.7 times book value, which was a lot more than the 1.98 times book value of Indonesia’s leading bank, Bank Mandiri, and of Maybank's own price-to-book multiple of 2.3 times.). Bank Internasional's shares traded at 310 rupiah yesterday, compared to the deal price of 510 rupiah.

''You can't do this,''
Achmad Fuad Rahmany, chairman of Indonesia's market regulator, said in an interview in Jakarta yesterday. Renegotiating the price ``will cause losses to investors.'' OH YES WE CAN, just like the way you enforced a "selling down clause" in your approval for the Maybank deal. That clause basically altered the strategic value behind the deal. The deal terms may be agreed upon, but always upon the deal being approved by the relevant authorities. Now the authorities have "materially changed" the strategic value of the deal. Maybank can walk away and lose their deposit. What do you mean "you can't do this", Encik Achmad???

When Maybank was faced with the embarrasing situation of losing the deposit for having to walk away - the sellers DID NOT offer a way out for Maybank, knowing full well that Bank Negara was making life hell for Maybank with the additional clause inserted by the Indonesian authorities. Maybank was getting slammed (correctly) for not tightening the deal terms (e.g. deal off if approval is not gotten from the Indonesian authorities, or if there are conditional "changes" to the deal when being approved by the Indonesian authorities).


Make no mistake, i am not siding with Maybank here - in fact the people responsible for the deal should sent back to school.

So to the buggering sellers offering the 480 million ringgit discount - go fly my wau! Too little too late.


Maybank, take your medicine and walk away, lose 400 million ringgit OK what... but surely SOME BLOODY heads must roll - who were the advisors, who were the legal advisors, who were the managers in charge of negotiating the deal???


Temasek and Kookmin, go find your Alan Bond scalp somewhere else!


... and its a celebratory Raya at Bank Negara after all...

p/s photo: Jamie Yeo