skip to main | skip to sidebar

Business Genesis

tips, tricks, business, news, information, services, business, SEO, internet, websites, blogs, business, news, health, facebook, twitter, automotive, online marketing, unique, funny, zodiac, sport

Showing posts with label EPF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EPF. Show all posts

EPF To Buy PLUS Expressways?

Is this a scoop? THis was reported in an exciting newish blog named Taikuns & Taikors. It now looks like sensibility has won the day with EPF entering the fray to buy PLUS Expressways. I can so no better solution to that. This toll system is too ingrained to be in private hands. At least now, all profits will accrue to EPF holders.

Deepika Padukone


http://www.tnt.net.my/home

Some twelve million EPF members are in for a windfall as the huge profit stream from Plus will directly boost yearly interest payout to exceed the current average of five percent, though earlier MMC Corp and Asas Serba proposals to buyout Plus are rejected.

The government has given the nod for the Employees Provided Fund to acquire Malaysia's largest tolled highway operator, Plus Expressways Bhd, putting an end to the attempts of two private companies to take over the Khazanah-owned entity.

EPF’s late-entry acquisition pips the proposals made separately by Tan Sri Syed Mokhtar Al-Bukhary’s MMC Corporation Bhd and Tan Sri Halim Saad’s Asas Serba Sdn Bhd to buyout Plus through Khazanah Nasional Bhd, which directly owns 16.74% of Plus and has an indirect stake of 38.51% via UEM Group.

Raising the roughly RM11 to RM12 billion to pay for the 55% of Plus shares now in Khazanah’s hands is considered as “loose change” as EPF has RM402 billion in total asset allocation as at March this year and would not require the pension fund to resort to the debt market.

Plus Expressways Bhd announced a traffic volume of 1,281.4 million Passenger Car Unit kilometer (PCU-km) in July, up four per cent compared with the same period last year.

Deepika Padukone

PLUS manages the North-South Expressway, New Klang Valley Expressway, Federal Highway Route Two and Seremban-Port Dickson Highway.

For the seven-month period ended July 30, traffic increased nine per cent to 9,916.7 million PCU-km from the previous corresponding period.

Meanwhile, its ELITE (North-South Expressway Central Link) subsidiary recorded 137.8 million PCU-km in July, an increase of 10.1 per cent from the corresponding period.


Year to date, traffic rose 13.6 per cent to 911.4 million PCU-KM against the the same period last year.

Read more: Plus Expressways posts 4pc traffic growth http://www.btimes.com.my/Current_News/BTIMES/articles/20100830182238/Article/index_html#ixzz10Sw1D41v


The shifting of a large chunk of a government controlled asset from one institution to another, is seen as the end of strategic assets being placed in the hands of individuals and ushering a new era of compliance on public accountability.

At a stroke, some 12.7 million EPF members will enjoy a windfall, as analysts compute the added cash flow from Plus to EPF will see its members gaining an extra one or two percent in annual interest payout from the present average of 5 percent.

In recent weeks there has been an unprecedented surge in the share price of Plus, touching its all-time high recently of RM4.32 on September 1 from its 52 week low of RM3.20.

Commenting on the government’s move to shift a strategic asset from one institution to another as it matures, in this case transferring Plus from Khazanah to EPF, a senior local banker said, ”It really is a way of sharing corporate profits directly with the public so people can gain from well run business operations within the government stable.”

A stock analyst familiar with the deal adds that the government has taken a lot of brickbats in the past for awarding contracts to individuals and this move marks the end of an era of placing strategic assets in the hands of individuals.

Deepika Padukone


“Almost all the past corporate debacles stemmed from individuals being trusted to manage national assets or assets of strategic importance. However, a mix of over-gearing and perhaps, over-ambition, led to their eventual failure which saw the government being forced to bail them out.

“In fact, Plus was once under the Renong Group and Khazanah was asked to take it over, rehabilitate the company and put in place a strict code of corporate governance.

Plus today is a really top-notch operation that is rated one of the world’s top five tolled highway operators.

“From Putrajaya’s viewpoint, it makes sense to transfer Plus to another state institution that pays out dividends directly to millions of Malaysians. We have to see this as a signal from the present administration that they are using a fresh approach to pass on profits generated by state-controlled companies to the man-in-the-street.

At the same time, the old practice of awarding large-scale state assets to individuals has come to an end,” he said.

The Plus purchase caps an acquisition spree by EPF which saw it take control of property developer MRCB and bank holding company RHB Capital, as a means of controlling large-scale profit generators to pay out a steady dividend pipeline to its members.
Posted by admin
Labels: deepika padukone, EPF, PLUS Expressways

EPF Top Equity Holdings

Not according to size or value but according to percentage control, below are EPF's significant equity holdings:

http://3critical.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/february-16-17-03431.jpg

Malaysia Building Society 67% - Its not well capitalised, don't see a need for MBSB to exists really. The company does not seem to have any strategy for growth. Sell it please or empower management to grow the business. No point holding onto this if nothing is done. Better still, put in an empowered new management with a roadmap.

RHB Capital 56% - Important stake. As the industry still needs to consolidate further, EPF is in the driver's seat to control its destiny. Do not be forced to marry an ugly duckling. Marry up. If HL Bank or even some Singapore bank comes knocking, at least say yes to a date.

MRCB 41.5% - I am not sure if this MRCB holding is a genuine equity holding or being used as a pseudo government tool. The lackluster general offer was directionless. Where is MRCB going? Make sure it is not a dumping ground for iffy projects, otherwise good. Need to improve KPIs on this vehicle, management seem too laid back. Crack the whip please.

http://www.asianpopcorn.com/battle_images/carmen_soo-200810221629313.jpg

Media Prima 24% - OK with the absorption of NSTP. Guess somebody has to hold the sensitive media vehicle. We should also know that Media Prima has no value in the open market as the government does not allow just anybody to control the shares. So, EPF has to ask why they are holding this, is this an investment or as we using our funds to do some other things with a differing objective? Does this help EPF to ensure our funds are being invested in a growth vehicle?

WCT 23% - OK to hold.

IJM 19.8% - Good hold, may want to gradually increase it. EPF should play a consultative role in ensuring there is a smooth transition of management in order to ensure the company's drive and strategy remain in place.

Cycle & Carriage Bintang 19% - OK to hold. OK to sell as well.

Star Publication 17% - Same reasoning as Media Prima.

Tenaga 16.8% - A must have no matter how you cut it.

DIGI 16.8% - OK to hold but must be rebalanced as the industry fights its way through 3G and market share.

Axiata 16.5% - Good stake.

Shell 16.3% - Legacy holding, OK I guess.

UMW 16% - One of the better managed companies, look to increase it to 20% please.

Public Bank 16% - Hmmm ... good holding obviously, could be interesting with RHB. Watch this space.

CarmenSoo.jpg image by teeweiong


Proton 15.5% - EPF must use their influence on the board and management to enter a viable partnership with a big foreign player. Only that way can Proton realise a market value close to its NAV.

CIMB 15.4% - Back to my prediction, CIMB-Public Bank, EPF would be a key player here. Now you know why the HEAD of EPF is such an important position. Good stake, should look to increase to 20%.

Dialog 15% - So-so, can sell if management's roadmap is not solid enough.

Alliance Financial Group 15% - Good holding.

Genting Plantation 15% - Not the best plantation counter, look to sell and move to better plantation counters please.

KLK 14.8% - Good stock.

SP Setia 14.7% - Good holding, empower management to grow further. Increase stake to 20%.

Sime Darby 14.6% - EPF is stuck here, can never consider to sell this, so you better get better managers there.

Sunrise 13% - Why?

IOI Corp 13% - Why so low?
Posted by admin
Labels: Carmen Soo Wai Mun, EPF

Comments On October Budget




As a Malaysian business and finance site, I guess I am expected to post some comments on the Budget. You may or may not like Najib, but as a Finance Minister, I think he has the best grasp of economic and finance issues compared to the Finance Ministers we have had for the past 20 years. Normally we see funds being thrown about and that's that. He has obviously been well advised, most of the measures are well defined with timelines and deadlines.

The strategy is to focus more on what we do well, what we have inherent strengths. The overall bigger picture is to ensure higher incomes for all - i.e. moving up the value add curve. The budget was very responsible, Najib could have taken the easy route and spend and spend with abandon. There are still a lot issues naturally if we wish to move up the value curve - the most pressing has to be the subsidy mentality. We need a complete overhaul of how we view the subsidy, we need to set timelines to gradually eradicate it except for the most basic and necessary products - at the same time, these removal / reduction of subsidies need to be balance in that the most affected will not suffer too much.

The overall budget will be taken positively by most foreign research houses, it provided strong soundbites, says the right things. I would say that the stock market should surprise most with a good performance.


* Government to reduce maximum individual income tax rate from 27% to 26% for chargeable income group exceeding RM100,00. Personal relief increase from RM8,000 to RM9,000 in 2010. This means that each individual taxpayer will enjoy an increase of RM1,000 in disposable income.* Govt to allocate RM899m for tourism industry in 2010, attract more participants from UK, Japan, Korea under Malaysia, My Second Home. (The man on the street always on the lookout for more take home pay. While that is a narrow perspective, more cash is always good, and judging from our high-ish tax rates compared to the rest in the region, this is a good move.)

* Govt to speed up implementation of high speed broadband at total cost of RM11.3b,of which RM2.4 billion is from government and RM8.9 billion from Telekom Malaysia. (Very important. It smacks at our overall competitiveness. Crucially there is a dateline to rollout in KL by March next year, and the rest of the country a gradual rollout by 2012.)

* Govt proposes individual taxpayers be given tax relief on broadband subscription fee up to RM500 a year from 2010 to 2012. (Good move.)

* Govt to allocate RM9b for infrastructure, of which RM4.7b for road, bridge, water, sewerage projects and RM900m for rail. (Good addition to the "earlier stimulus package", did not go overboard.)

* Govt to look into micro insurance, takaful coverage. Premiums from as low as RM20 per month for small traders, coverage from RM10k to RM20k.

* Flexible brokerage sharing between stockbrokers, remisers. Flexible brokerage at 40% for remisers. To be fully liberalised in second stage by Jan 1, 2011. (Will allow more aggressive brokers to snatch remisiers. Expect Singapore houses to be more aggressive here.)

* Allow 100pct foreign equity stake in corporate finance, financial, planning companies from at least 30pct local stake now. (Good move although many have been doing these deals out of the country anyway.)

* For upstream petroleum companies, income tax for yr assessment 2010 based on 2009 income can be paid over 5 years. (Allows for better reinvestment and cost/revenue matching.)

* Govt to impose 5pct tax imposed on gains from disposal of real property from Jan 1, 2010. However, it will be retained for gifts between parent and child, husband and wife, grandparent and grandchild. This tax exemption will also be given on disposal of residential property once in a lifetime. (Property companies will not be pleased with the reintroduction of RPGT, but its a pre-emptive move, considering the "better leverage to borrow from Account 2 of EPF" for purchases. 5% is fair and will keep a lid on things, a hint on things that Bank Negara may be keeping rates low for a few more months. Low rates, which is necessary to keep ample liquidity in the system, is targeted to boost lending to business and create/save jobs. An indirect nasty would be channeling it to push property prices higher - the RPGT is to keep things on a more equal footing.)

* Govt proposes RM50 service tax on each principal credit card, charge cards, including free cards. RM25 for supplementary cards by January. (Could AEON Credit be affected, guess so, we really need just one card people, any more than that is license to fuck ourselves up.)

* Govt to impose RM10,000 for each approved permit to open AP holders, for distribution of AP in 2010. (Not good enough, needs to place a timeline to scrap it, say within 3 years, and the levy needs to be closer to market price of RM30,000.)

* Govt to implement fuel subsidy management system in early 2010, using MyKad, to ensure targeted groups will benefit.

* Govt to reduce maximum individual income tax rate from 27pct to 26pct, personal relief increase from RM8,000 to RM9,000 in 2010. (Cannot complain but we need the top rates to come down some more to incentivise entreprenuers. If the money makers are not making money, the ones below will not do well.)

* Govt to launch scheme for EPF contributors to use current, future savings in account 2 to get higher financing to buy higher value house or additional houses. (Need deatils but generally positive.)

* Govt to issue 1Malaysia sukuk totaling RM3b, for Malaysian aged 21 and above. 3yr maturity, with 5pct annual rate of return

* 1Malaysia retirement scheme for self-employed, run by EPF. For every RM100 contribution, govt to contribute 5pct, maximum RM60.

* Personal tax relief raised to RM7,000 from RM6,000 now for EPF contribution and life insurance premiums. (We should have a timeline, RM1,000 increase every year till RM10,000.)


p/s photos: Noon Wongsawan
Posted by admin
Labels: EPF, EPF Account 2, Malaysian Budget, najib razak, tax cuts

The M'sian X-Files - Intricacies Of The New FBM KLCI




There is a lot of new information that one can get on the new index, which will help us to understand the index and the markets better. It will also help to get a better grasp as to the "integrity of the FBM KLCI" when it rises and falls.

a) Its just 30 counters instead of the old KLCI which had 100 counters.

b) The new index addresses issues such as liquidity and free float, and let's face it funds in general are really looking at just the top 30... heck throw in another 20 stocks and that's their universe.

c) There is a good chance that the 30 stocks will start to be traded at a premium to the rest as these are the must haves for all indexed funds, by all the big and small local funds, and by most of the foreign fund managers managing Asian portfolio so as to not be under performing the Asian benchmarks.

d) Having said that, part of the rise in the FBM KLCI over the last 2 weeks may be attributed to some of these sustained 'enforced buying' activity rather than by genuine equity players.

e) The new index is a skewed index. Banks and plantations alone have a total weighting of 55%. If you have banks, plantations and telco = 63%. If you add banks, plantations, power, gaming and telco = 85%. So, technically a fund manager need only look seriously at these FIVE SECTORS alone to do well, forget about the rest.

f) The new index will also affect how research houses form their analyst teams. They must cover the 5 sectors, there are 9 sector that are not covered by the new index. It is very likely that analysts in the following sectors better start covering a more important sector in order to stay relevant. The following are the 9 sectors that are deemed as "irrelevant", "need not exist", "unimportant to the Malaysian economy", "unnecessary to look at in order to gauge the overall health of the economy": technology, transportation, property, timber, insurance, construction, building materials, hotels and industrial products. Go figure!

g) The new index will make it that much "easier" for the index to be controlled - conspiracy theorists will agree with me whole-heartedly that this is to allow PNB-EPF-MOF-EPU to control the index better. So, the next time we see a major market correction, we may be able to withstand it better with the new index as all it takes is to mop up the 30 stocks ... even though those stocks outside of the top 30 may be seeing their share prices tumbling like a rock. Managed perception more important la... than real effects to the economy. Hey, like that, we may never ever see a major correction in the FMB KLCI... ever... especially if we keep launching new big funds to mop these buggers up. But I am only guessing here.

h) Now let's consider the sin stocks, gaming and tobacco, they account for 12% of the new index. This is an important consideration as most of the big local funds will not be touching these stocks. Can you "not be in control of the 12% of the index" and still manage funds that is compared to the FBM KLCI benchmark? If these 12% of the new index starts a bull run on its own, most of the local funds will be under performing the new index. Can you all see a danger here??? Staring at you in the face!!! The danger is ... if there ever occurs a situation where you get the gaming and tobacco stocks to be in a strong bull run outperforming the rest of the new indexed stocks ... could we safely say that the EPU-MOF will not be strong-armed or "influenced" by certain parties to "whack down the sin stocks" with excessive punitive measures ( additional gaming and duties above and beyond what is normally expected in a financial year)???

g) If you take Khazanah, Petronas and PNB as the investing triumvirate ... the 3 already control 12 out of the 30 stocks in FBM KLCI. If you are a nasty anti-government critic, you have enough loose thoughts to take this factor to the next level. I am not saying its a negative or a positive, but its a fact that is worth remembering. Be careful, as the greater the influence one has, the greater the responsibility to be prudent, transparent and professional.

h) Though most fund managers will want to stick to the FBM 100 as the benchmark for their performance, it will not be so easy. The drivel, the propaganda and focus have all been set to make FBM KLCI the index to watch, and because it was kinda close to the level where the old KLCI was, most will tend to take to this new index. Its much harder if you switch from a 1,100 index level to a 9,500 one ... kudos to the planners.

i) Of course detractors will point to the fact that the venerated Dow Jones Industrial Index is only made up of 30 stocks, and is an often quoted barometer, even though most professional funds benchmark their performance to the broader S&P 500. The big difference is that it will be a hundred times easier to try to "manipulate" the FBM KLCI than the Dow Jones Industrial Index. Actually, pick just any two stocks in the Dow Jones, I am VERY SURE the market cap of any two stocks will be bigger than total market cap of ALL stocks listed on Bursa - in fact just any ONE stock in the top 10 of DJIA will be enough to cover the entire market cap of Bursa. Not to belittle FBM KLCI but to put things in perspective.

Can I have my Datukship now??!! (yea, I don't really need one or want one... but I want to get on and off my plane faster la...).


p/s photos: Yukie Nakama
Posted by admin
Labels: banks market cap, Bursa, CPO, djia, dow jones, EPF, fbm 100, FBM KLCI, FTSE, Khazanah, malaysian telcos, petronas, Plantations, PNB, Yukie Nakama

Decoding PNB's Investment Strategy Ahead



Time to try and decode PNB's investing strategy, as some have voiced concerns over its last few fixed priced funds, and its ability to maintain those returns. Some of the information have been extracted from articles in The Edge.

Four of the 10 PNB funds are known as fixed-price funds where the price per unit is fixed at RM1 regardless of how the market performed. There is a history behind this practice. The first PNB fund, Amanah Saham Nasional, was launched as a fixed-price fund in 1981 but it reverted back to market pricing in 1991 as per the trust deed. Soon after that, Amanah Saham Bumiputera, a fixed-price fund was launched in 1990 for investors not accustomed to market fluctuations. Altogether, there are four such funds by PNB.

Fixed-price funds are practically risk-free as investors get back whatever they put in if or when they redeem their investments. On top of that, you get generous returns of 7% to 8% every year. It is a very good deal indeed but on the other side of the coin, the actual value of the underlying investments is unknown, unlike other unit trust funds where you know the value of your investments at any point in time. The balance sheets of fixed-price funds are not disclosed in their annual reports, and the Securities Commission, the body governing the unit trust industry, grants these funds various exemptions from its guidelines on unit trust funds.

How can a fund keep paying 6%-8% a year in dividend, invested 60%-90% in local equities, and will always have a fixed price of RM1 NAV. You cannot get that anywhere else, can you? Is anybody even a bit curious? PNB is not almighty. What about the 1997-1998 Asian crisis, the Internet meltdown, the 9-11 period, the SARS debacle, and the very recent subprime global meltdown ... surely we all saw that equity prices were hammered for an extended period.

The way PNB would argue is that they do income smoothing, or something along those lines. That in good year, say they get an 11% return, they will keep some of the gains and declare only 7% in dividends. The excess would go into a special performance account to top up future years that they do not have stellar dividends. That sounds alright except that you still did not know the exact real NAV of these funds.

PNB could very well be paying 6%-8% dividend every year on these fixed price funds but the real NAV may be deteriorating below RM1.00, and we don't know because its not known. Should we be concerned if the actual collective real NAV of these fixed priced funds were to be say RM0.97, RM0.93 and RM0.88 for 2006, 2007 and 2008 respectively??? We can only assume that their real NAV is healthy.

In good or bad markets, the funds have consistently returned steady dividends in the high single digit. But the fact is, the returns are lower today than in the 1980s and 1990s when dividends and bonuses were in the double-digit realm (as high as 20% for ASN in 1981). But no one is complaining about the 7% to 8% annual return today considering that investments in the fixed-price funds are essentially risk-free — you get your principal back when you sell your units.

PNB is a unique institution. I can understand how they can generate double digit return in the early years (PNB was established in 1979). Pernas, which had been acquiring public-listed companies under foreign control, was compelled to transfer 13 of its companies, including Sime Darby Bhd and Malaysia Mining Corp Bhd, to PNB at cost. Malayan Banking Bhd was transferred to PNB after Bank Negara Malaysia stepped in to restructure the bank in 1967 following a bank run, which wiped out 40% of its deposit base. PNB also benefited from grants and interest-free loans from the government to facilitate the acquisitions. By 1989, PNB had transferred to ASN sizeable stakes in various listed entities. Similarly, ASB’s assets comprised those transferred from PNB. Furthermore, as a bumiputera institution and one of the biggest institutional investors in town, PNB is said to have been allotted shares in companies en route to listing at attractive prices, given the need to meet the 30% bumiputera shareholding requirement.

In the 90s PNB still had its channels as many big companies got listed, and IPOs generally performed outstandingly during the early 90s bull run. Over the last few yers, these mega IPOs have dried up. PNB will now have to rely on corporate finance and restructuring to generate value to its stable of companies. Hence, arguably, the Sime Darby's mega plantation scheme is the start of many more projects under PNB's auspices. PNB will now have to consolidate its stable of companies, put them into synergistic groupings to create more value. All that is very necessary to continue to support these fixed priced funds that still give 6%-8% dividend income every year and can always be redeemed at RM1.00 par.

So, the scepticism over PNB's ability to maintain these returns is genuine and needed to be asked. As to whether they can do it depends on execution, the advisors they have, and how astute they are at not just managing funds but including appointing the right people to manage the synergies and put the collective resources to work. Sime Darby is still digesting the huge plantation firms acquired. It is imperative that PNB maintain a very high standard of professionalism in its retention of top management executives in running these merged entities. PNB has to minimise the political interference to have political appointees - it has to manage with clear transparency with global best practices as their mantra.

The next big project for PNB has to be its many property companies under its stable. PNB have SP Setia and Mah Sing, and its stakes in these companies have been "rising strategically". In contrast, PNB has accumulated almost 20% in Mah Sing and has direct and indirect interests of close to 32.9% in S P Setia. Another company that PNB has bought a stake in is I-Bhd, where it has 18.1%. Sime Darby Property could be better placed in a property conglomerate as it has the largest landbank in the country. Sime Darby’s landbank in the Klang Valley stretches from the Guthrie Corridor in the north of Selangor, to Putrajaya, Seremban and Port Dickson. The 37,000 acres in its landbank is about as big as Kuala Lumpur and three times the size of Putrajaya.

PNB took Petaling Garden Bhd, Island & Peninsular Bhd and Pelangi Bhd private between 2005 and 2007. The three collectively own 7,200 hectares of land. Apart from land, PNB also has buildings in prime locations that can easily be packaged into a real estate investment fund (REIT). Within its fold is also Syarikat Perumahan Pegawai Kerajaan Sdn Bhd (SPPK), which has a good property development record. Because of its huge landbank, Mah Sing and S P Setia are said to be possible vehicles for PNB to unlock value.

It looks increasingly like PNB want Sime Darby to concentrate on plantations. Hiving off SDP to a merged Mah Sing-SP Setia vehicle would probably yield great value to Sime Darby and ramps up PNB's control in Mah Sing-SP Setia. PNB holds about 53% stake in Sime Darby, which wholly owns Sime Property.

Imagine if PNB injects the three property developers – Island & Peninsular Bhd, Petaling Garden Bhd and Pelangi Bhd – all privatised between 2005 and 2007, as well into the merged SPSetia-Mah Sing vehicle. Its a mega property concern for sure. The good thing is that it can consolidate its landbank in one major masterplan and plan much better strategically. It will be much better capitalised as well to venture into new markets with various "brands" for the right markets.

I doubt very much PNB will take SP Setia or Mah Sing private. Injecting what they have into SP Setia-Mah Sing would make much more sense. The whole shebang would require massive amount of capital for development and venturing into new markets, you wouldn't want to take that onto PNB's balance sheets as we could be talking in billions of ringgit every few years.

Other institutional shareholders of SP Setia include the Employees Provident Fund with 12%, Capital Group of the US also with 12%, and other foreign shareholders which hold another 14% in the company. On June 18, SP Setia announced the appointment of two nominees of PNB – Tan Sri Wan Mohd Zahid Mohd Noordin and Datuk Noor Farida Mohd Ariffin – as its new non-independent and non-executive directors. SP Setia’s two executive directors – Khor Chap Jen and Teow Leong Seng – resigned from their positions on the same day. However, both remain with the company in their existing capacity as executive vice-president in charge of property division (central) and executive vice-president/CEO of international business development respectively.


p/s photo: Maya Karin
Posted by admin
Labels: Amanah Saham 1 Malaysia, asm, asn, ASW, ASW2020, EPF, fixed priced funds, Island and Peninsular, mah sing, maya karin, pelangi, petaling garden, PNB, Sime Darby, sime darby property, sp setia

Clarifying Your EPF Beneficiary Status



Reuben Puan wrote to Soo Ewe Jin of Star Biz on some EPF matters on beneficiaries. Soo forwarded the mail to EPF and got the official reply from EPF. The subject matter is important, do read the content and see if your beneficiary for your EPF and prevalent issues need your further attention:


Dear Reuben,

Thank you for your query which has been referred directly to me by Mr. Soo Ewe Jin.

Please find our responses below:

1. What precedes the EPF......the will or the EPF nomination?

The EPF nomination will always supercede the will.


2. Suppose I nominate 25% each for my son and daughter and the remainder 50% for my spouse, if an accident were to befall both of us, then what happen? Will my children be getting 50% each automatically?

Should an EPF member dies at the same time as his or her nominee, the nomination portion that was bequeathed to that nominee will be invalid. Therefore if an accident were to befall both you and your spouse, 50 percent cent of your EPF savings or the nomination portion which has been bequeathed to your spouse will be invalid.

This 50 per cent will be subjected to procedures under 'EPF savings without nomination' in which the first priority for the right to claim the member's savings goes to the appointed administrator of the deceased member's estate.

This therefore means that 50 per cent of your EPF's savings will not be paid automatically to your children.


3. Furthermore, if fate would have it that the 4 of us suddenly meet our maker, then what is the outcome?

The same principle applies as above i.e. the nominations will be invalid. In such a case, withdrawal of EPF savings will be subjected to procedures under EPF savings without nomination' in which the first priority for the right to claim the member's savings goes to the appointed administrator of the deceased member's estate.


I hope the above answers have helped to shed some light to your queries. If you have any other queries, please email me.


Thanks and best regards,

Nik Affendi Jaafar

General Manager,
Public Relations, EPF



p/s photos: Li Xiao Lu
Posted by admin
Labels: EPF, epf beneficiary, li xiao lu

No! Not From The EPF Please!




Saw this in Malaysian Insider: KUALA LUMPUR, July 28 — A government agency which is administrating two schemes under the first economic stimulus package is in talks with the employees’ pension fund for a RM5 billion, a business daily said.

The Malaysian Reserve, citing an unidentifed source today, said the Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF) was ready to fund the loan at an undisclosed rate to Prokhas, the government-owned special purpose vehicle.

The source added that Prokhas was also looking at other financing options including government bonds, private debt securities or a term loan that may give more competitive rates. Malaysia announced its first stimulus package of RM60 billion in March to shore up the export-reliant economy against the global economic crisis.

http://www.karazen.com/media/stephy/010.jpg



Prokhas manages two schemes under the package and was allocated 5 billion ringgit each, known as Working Capital Guarantee Scheme and the Industry Restructuring Loan Scheme, which is under the Ministry of Finance.

EPF’s talks with Prokhas may draw some criticism, as loans to government agencies and corporations have in the past been called bailouts for poorly performing local companies by critics and the resurgent opposition.

In 2008, the government said it would transfer RM5 billion from the EPF to state owned fundmanager Valuecap to be invested in undervalued Malaysian stocks. — Reuters

----------------

I can understand, even though I may not fully support EPF's role in lending to Valuecap, it is still a legitimate usage of funds to invest in equity. The rumours that Prohas is asking for RM5bn from EPF needs to be stopped even before it gets to Najib's desk. Past experiences have told us that the majority of loans to government agencies and corporations did not have a happy ending. History will tell us that in the end, the government will end up making up for the losses, in this case when EPF loses money on the RM5bn causing the public to be in total disgust.

People can understand why they lost money when its in stocks. People will not be so understanding when its used as Working Capital Guarantee Scheme and the Industry Restructuring Loan Scheme. There have been many great and long serving public servants, making damn sure over the decades that the EPF remains an institution of integrity, where the contributors' savings can be managed responsibly for their retirement. DO NOT undo the decades of disciplined investing philosophy by "forcing" EPF to do this - working capital guarantee and loan restructuring... certainly not EPF's forte, and neither do I think Prokhas has an edge in doing this. There is no guarantee of a return, its corporate restructuring, recovery, rehabilitation, valuation & disposal, breakup value assessment, etc .... certainly not EPF's normal mode or channel of investments.

EPF can and should only expose itself to a certain kind of risk (and its usually very very low). What risk are we exposing EPF to when it starts to "lend" this RM5bn?

Even if Prokhas can get the government to guarantee EPF's money and even a decent return... guess whose money is the government using to repay EPF??!! Its still our money. Just because we use different terminologies or canisters, it does not mean the money somehow does not belong to the people. I hope this will remain as just rumours.

If the scheme is solid and has the structure to stand on its own, go raise the funding from overseas banks. Why I don't see the Japanese, US or European banks and investment bankers lining up for this??? If this can only be "sourced locally", ask ourselves why... don't kid ourselves. If the foreign banks will not fund this, ask why. This is NOT to say we should not do this... in fact I think we should... but don't la play-play with EPF's money, its not a standby ATM-piggy bank for all to rape.

Dudes .... please...


p/s photos: Stephy Tang Lai Yan



Posted by admin
Labels: EPF, prokhas, stephy tang lai yan

Revamping Our Pension Scheme


  • News reports indicated that the government will roll out a private pension scheme initiative by the middle of next year, as part of its reforms to the existing pension funds industry.
  • Securities Commission task force will submit a report on the private pension scheme to the government in the next six months.
  • "There will be three legs under the pension reforms - the government pension scheme, the EPF and the private pension funds," he said. Nor Mohamed said the EPF scheme will be reviewed since the government does not want one fund to constitute the major portion of the Malaysian capital market.
My views:

- Will this mean EPF does not have the capacity to invest more funds? Or is EPF running out of local cagamas / bonds to park the funds to?
- EPF might be taking the proper route here in that it can only manage a certain projected return of 4%-6% if 70% of their funds are in top rated ringgit papers, the rest primarily in local stocks and the rest in overseas stocks. If they put too much in foreign currency bonds or foreign stocks, EPF will have a lot less control of the investments. The foreign currency aspect will swing returns to unacceptable territory. How would you like your EPF annual returns to be swinging between the range of -3% to +8%?
- The major development is to help cover those 2 million currently outside the ambit of EPF, that is a noble thing to do.
- The secondary objective is to provide "approved funds" to take the burden off EPF. If it was up to me, I would suggest that one should have the option of putting 50% - 100% of contribution for EPF to manage. If you wish, you can allocate up to 50% of your EPF funds into approved funds.
- Let's remember the wonderful example of the USA's 401k, you get to choose to put your 401k into funds. Many people lost 30%-60% of their 401k. Now please imagine losing 30% to 60% of your retirement EPF funds in just one year.
- Sure you could also get those who can get superior returns in the 401k, but is that what a superannuation fund is for? You do not need the 20%-30% return a year for something like your superannuantion fund. First objective of a super fund: DON'T LOSE ANY MONEY. Second objective: Make something decent that is a bit above prevailing interest rate.
- Anything more than that will result in greater returns, yes, but as well as greater risk. Talk to those who lost 30% to 60% in their 401k, I am sure they would have loved to have been in EPF from day one.
- Some who speculate that compulsory contributions to EPF will be cut is looking at the wrong angle. Overall contributions won't be cut, but the public will have the choice to allocate to other approved funds.
- This WILL NOT mean EPF will then cut their stakes in local companies, that is flawed thinking. EPF will not need to cut its stakes at all.
- The SC will have to be very careful in selecting the approved funds. I hope not to see favouritism. Approved local funds should have size (proven size, managed decent sums before, RM300m for equity, RM1bn for bonds), proved records for at least 3 years, preferably 5 years. I would want to see some foreign funds being approved as well, the criteria could be more stringent, minimum US$500m for 5 years of beating respective benchmarks, US$3bn for bond funds and minimum 5 year track records. Some attention should be paid to foreign currency exposure - while most international funds are valued at USD, a fund that is somewhat "hedged to the ringgit" will help. For example if Aberdeen Asset wants to be an approved fund, it will need to mark their returns for that fund back to ringgit even when running a foreign equity or bonf fund.
- When selecting an approved fund, do not get bogged down using too many parameters. The alphas, betas and gammas can be very distracting. The risk measure is ok as its a good indicator to see how much risk is required to get their required returns. Turnover is a so-so measure, let the fund manager manage his/her way. Is it a personality driven fund or otherwise, state out how you would regard each category, what to do when the star fund manager leaves. I would watch closely the cost of entry and exit as this is public money. I would strongly advise to have lots of indexed funds, which will have very low management fees (many are below 0.75% p.a.). Many funds have to charge 3% to buy into their funds because they rely too much on agents, discard them. If you want to be an approved fund, entry/mgmt fee together should not be more than 1.5% p.a., the public should not have to bother with the fact that you do not have size. Its not a personal investment issue, its a national retirement fund.
- While we are at it, revamping EPF, please come up with a viable ANNUITY plan. Its a simple plan, it has been mooted before, why are the insurance companies so greedy - kick out those greedy ones. This is very pressing because we know that more than half of all retirees finish ALL their EPF monies within 3 years. That defeats the purpose of retirement income.
- An ANNUITY plan would allow pensioners to buy units of Annuity for life. For example, if it cost RM60,000 for one unit that would pay RM500 per month for life ... (an expert could come up with a more realistic calculation, I am not an actuary). Then one could buy 3 units for RM180,000 upon retirement and will be guaranteed RM1,500 tax free per month for life, and so on.
- It does not have to be compulsory, but there has to be a credible choice upon retirement.




p/s photos: Cherry Ann Kubota



Posted by admin
Labels: annuity, cherry ann kubota, EPF, epf returns

EPF vs LTAT Again


As usual, every time EPF declares its annual dividend, there will be scores of groups who will be up in arms at how the returns could have been so much higher. A disclaimer: I have not been paid a retainer or fee by EPF for writing this posting. Many people have been wondering how and why LTAT can post such enviable earnings and dividends to its members for the past few years. Why can't EPF even come close to it? The Lembaga Tabung Angkatan Tentera (LTAT) group posted a 45.1% rise in pre-tax profit to RM1.5 billion for its financial year ended Dec 31, 2007, on the back of a record gross income of RM616.9 million. Just recently, for the year 2008, the Lembaga Tabung Angkatan Tentera (Malaysian Armed Forces Fund) is rewarding its contributors with a 7% dividend, 3% bonus and 6% special bonus.

The total dividends and bonus for 2008 would be 16%, which was in line with 2007. The total amount would be RM597.9 million, up 8.3% from RM552.2 million a year ago. The superannuation fund said on March 13 that it recorded pre-tax profit of RM631.4 million for the year ended Dec 31 last year, a 2.3% increase from the RM616.9 million in 2007. LTAT said the pre-tax profit was the highest since the Asian financial crisis in 1997. It recorded pre-tax profit of RM697.6 million in 1996. Its total assets as at Dec 31 had increased by 8% to RM7.2 billion and the total contributions last year were RM4.8 billion from the 116,000 contributors.

To be fair, there is no way for EPF to even come close to LTAT's performance because the mandate is very different, and EPF is also very much hampered by its sheer size. Most of EPF funds are in bonds and that will anchor the performance a lot. Whereas LTAT is managing around RM5bn only.

We will get a better idea on LTAT by looking at their policies. From its website: On the investment front, it has always been LTAT's policy to adopt investment strategies whereby investments are spread out in as many sectors and industries as possible to ensure stability of returns in whatever type of economic environment, and to provide steady growth in investments in the long term.
As part of its long term strategy, LTAT has substantial investment in the plantation industry to take advantage of good prospects of the agricultural sector. LTAT has also taken up investments in property development and participated in companies involved in the manufacturing of building materials. To further enhance its income in property development, LTAT has entered into joint ventures with foreign and local investors to undertake industrial, residential and new township development.

In the financial services sector, LTAT has controlling interest in a number of financial institutions including a commercial bank, a merchant bank, a finance company, a general insurance company, a discount house, a money broking house, a stockbroking company and an asset management company.

In the medium and heavy industries sector, LTAT has acquired substantial interest in a number of prominent companies involved in steel milling, and the manufacture of industrial gas and electrical cables.LTAT also has interests in a number of companies in the transportation sector in particular those dealing in the assembling and distribution of motor vehicles and heavy equipment and the manufacture of automotive component parts. In the telecommunications industry, LTAT is involved in the supply and installation of fixed and mobile telecommunication equipment, exchanges and infrastructure network.

Under the superannuation scheme, serving members of the other ranks in the Armed Forces are required to contribute 10% of their monthly salary to LTAT with the government as employer contributing 15%. For officers, participation is voluntary and the contributions are a minimum of RM 25 with a maximum of RM750 monthly.

Looking at LTAT's portfolio, they include Asiatic, Boustead, Affin and BP. Like it or not, by sheer luck or good planning, almost every single exposure had a wonderful run over the last 4 years (yes, Affin had it difficult for a long time). Oil, plantations, property and financials - is it any wonder why they did not do well. Not to mention building materials as well. However all businesses are cyclical and they will not always be that good. There will come a time where these sectors will be on a down cycle, and we will see dividends of LTAT being pulled back to the mean. Still, they have manged to set very good returns over the last 4 years and deserve a pat on their backs.

But let's be clear here, LTAT had a good run, their portfolio were in the right sectors. If you run a business and the sector had a strong upcycle, was it due to you or to macro factors? You can buy and select the business, call it that you made the top-down macro view work for you.

I would be more severe on LTAT's performance before they start congratulating each other. I would do peer-to-peer reviews on their companies especially since most are controlled vehicles and long term core holdings. Boustead Plantations is no hero when it comes to yield management. Affin is no leader in finance, in fact most performance metrics would be pretty unimpressive. You can do that to each business. Yes, their performance was good, but if they had improved in each business segment to be in the top quartile for their sector, they would have been looking at maybe 20% return for each of the last 4 years!

Despite all of LTAT's strong performance, I WOULD BE VERY VERY CAUTIOUS with LTAT's asset allocation. Its very high risk, and the fund may even see drastic losses in future owing to their type of exposure. You don't get 20% returns year in year out, without a strong likelihood of losing 20% as well. Somebody should really go through LTAT's mandate and strategy and rework it while no untoward damage as been done YET.

This should never be compared to EPF, they don't have the flexibility to just invest in just a handful of stocks owing to their size. We all should be happy with 4.5% now. Even the 5%-6% in 2006 and 2007 during strong bull runs is very good. Its a pension fund, you NEVER want your pension fund to take up so much risks, i.e. in equities... or invests in unnecessary risks such as foreign currency bonds. As EPF will be managing ringgit funds for Malaysians, the end story is that it must manage a decent rate of return in ringgit. Putting 80% or more in local bond papers is OK and necessary. If EPF had put 50% in stocks, the fund may have declared 12% returns in 2007 but in 2008, we could have zero or worse, -10%. Pension funds must not lose money.

The only danger I see is that EPF is increasingly looking to be the lender of last resort for local bond papers. That is an unhealthy development no matter how you cut it. Bank Negara should look into this area to mitigate the future risk.

On a side note, the FAQs below should not have highlighted other big foreign funds as most are not pension funds but sovereign wealth funds (don't think people are stupid la...). Compare apples with apples, just do it with CPF would be fine.
--------------------------

The Employees Provident Fund has declared 4.5 per cent dividend for 2008, its lowest since 2003. It provided a list of questions and answers that accompanied its statement on the dividend yesterday.

QUESTION: Why is the EPF’s dividend for 2008 lower than that for 2007?

Answer:
The EPF Board declared a dividend of 4.50 per cent for 2008. This dividend rate is lower compared to that of 2007 due to the increase in investment provisioning resulting from the sharp decline in global equity prices brought about by the worldwide financial crisis.

Although the EPF earned its highest ever gross income in 2008, the EPF has made provisions of RM4.69 billion for diminution in equity value after a sharp fall in equity prices as a consequence of the global financial crisis. This has significantly reduced our net earnings but this provision remains unrealised, as we have not sold off our shares. This provision will be written back once the equity markets recover.

Nonetheless, our dividend rate compares favourably with fixed-deposit rates offered by Malaysian banks. For instance, the current 12-month fixed-deposit rate for Malaysian banks is 2.50 per cent.Additionally, an increased amount is needed to pay 1 per cent dividend to members for 2008. For 2008, the EPF required RM3.18 billion to pay 1per cent dividend compared with only RM2.89 billion in 2007.


Q: Why was the provision made for 2008 much larger than 2007?

A:
The provision written into our books for 2008 is RM4.69 billion, of which RM3.2 billion was allocated for overseas equities. This figure is much higher than the provision for equity diminution in value in 2007, which was only RM0.52 billion. This provision is made due to the sharp drop in equity markets especially in the fourth quarter of last year. However, we are confident that this provision will be written back once recovery takes place.

Despite this provision, equities remained as the second biggest contributor to the EPF’s total gross income bringing in RM6.67 billion in 2008 compared with RM5.37 billion in 2007.

It should be highlighted that the EPF compares better than many other funds around the world. For example:

# The government pension fund of Norway suffered a US$92 billion loss on its investments in 2008. (BBC News, March 11 2009);

# Temasek Holdings suffered S$58 billion paper loss in eight months. (Singapore BT, February 11 2009);

# Government of Singapore Investment Corporation Private Ltd asset value fell 25 per cent from its peak. (Bloomberg, March 5 2009);

# California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) suffered a US$68 billion loss in assets since October 2007 and a 41 per cent slide in its stock portfolio. (Bloomberg, February 26 2009); and

# Khazanah Nasional Bhd suffered a loss of one fifth of its investment portfolio and its realisable asset value of RM88.2 billion as of May 31 was reduced to RM70.4 billion at the end of 2008. (BT, January 20 2009)

Q: What is the EPF’s forecast for 2009?

A:
We are bracing ourselves for a tough year ahead as the effects of the financial crisis continue to be felt. We expect 2009 to be a very challenging year, and the expected dividend will therefore not be more than 2008.

Q: How did the EPF manage to offer a dividend of 8 per cent in the 80s?

A:
In the 80s, EPF’s investments were concentrated on interest-based investments, such as Malaysian Government Securities (MGS). It should be noted that the interest rate regime during those years were high, with the average base lending rates (BLR) hitting a peak of 12.25 per cent in 1984, compared to the significantly lower current BLR.

Consequently, investments in MGS during that era were able to produce very high returns for the EPF, making it possible for the fund to declare its highest dividend rates. However, the high interest rate regime also meant that cost of housing loans and hire purchase were considerably higher at that time than they are now.

Q: How safe is my money in the EPF?

A:
Your money is very safe in the EPF. As a retirement fund, we will continue to maintain a prudent and low-risk investment policy backed by thorough research and in accordance with investment best practices.

Furthermore, the EPF Act 1991 guarantees that the dividend rate will not fall below 2.5 per cent.

Q: Why are other savings funds in Malaysia able to offer better dividends than the EPF?

A:
The simplest explanation is that other funds have different investment objectives. The EPF maintains an asset allocation structure that does not expose the investments to high risk in line with its role as a retirement fund. Other funds are also much smaller in size compared with the EPF which stands at RM340 billion.

p/s photos: Fala Chen
Posted by admin
Labels: EPF, LTAT, malaysian pension fund

Malaysia Needs Unemployment Insurance


Our government has been postponing the need for unemployment insurance for too long. We do not have sufficient safety nets underpinning our country's social and economic systems. The concern has always been the cost side. The other argument is the incentive not to work. There is a bigger danger in having unemployment insurance - companies may be more "willing" to bite the bullet to lay off workers in such an environment.

We already have too many archaic rules pervading the economic life of Malaysians. Its quite debilitating really. Its a system that highly favours the corporations and banks in particular. We have little in safety nets, yet our bankruptcy laws are so archaic and put Malaysians at a huge disadvantage. Linked closely to unemployment is bankruptcy. First, the sum which can bankrupt a person is only RM30,000. Its high time that that be raised to a more realistic level, say RM50,000.

Secondly, the bankruptcy is technically life long till the debt is totally repaid (although the Insolvensi department can recommend a person to be cleared after 7 or 8 years if he/she has been diligent in making monthly payments). Most countries will discharge a person under bankruptcy after 4 or 5 years. I believe in HK its 4 years. We should make it standardised that all should be cleared and discharged after 4 or 5 years. Even prison sentences don't run that long. The banks have all written the bad debts off already, now we are just trying to put in a reasonable time to collect the debts. The current system is not fair at all.

Thirdly, the Immigration department mentioned recently that some 13% of all Malaysian passport holders have their traveling access restricted because of bankruptcy and/or income tax non payment. The restrictions are usually lifted when the parties has struck a payment scheme with the relevant departments. We have seen so many defaulting on study loans and unnecessary credit card debts. Worse are those who stand as guarantors naively for loans. Imagine standing as guarantor for a RM200,000 loan and the person is nowhere to be found and the departments and banks come and get you instead.

Fourthly, the 13% figure is alarming, we need to revamp the laws immediately as it affects a substantial portion of the population. Locking them under archaic laws prevent many from owning properties and even rebuilding their equity, and as such prevent them from re-participating fully in the economy.

We have no unemployment insurance, and every 7-10 years we will have a massive recession and many might not be able to honour their commitments owing to forces greater than them. We can take the pedestal and say they deserve it for not being able to manage their financial affairs properly, but seriously, even drug addicts and prisoners get a second chance to rebuild their lives. I am not here to justify reckless behaviour, but to ask that the laws be fairer to the normal person. When you unfairly penalises a person, it does not just affect the person alone, in Malaysia's culture, people also have to take care of their parents and extended families. Hence the social impact is substantial.

I am not an insurance guy, but I think we can come up with a semi government body to do this, or even be part of EPF to do this. EPF can do this role well as it already has the database for checks and balances. How about all employees contribute 1.5% to this Fund and the employer puts in another matching 1.5% of salary. Only employees who have contributed more than 1 year will be able to enjoy the benefits. If you are laid off, you will get 3 months full pay and 5 months of half pay of your last salary. These will be paid like normal salaries on a monthly basis, thus covering most expenses for at least 8 months. This will be in additional to the normal notice pay and severance pay. Once you have taken the unemployment benefits, you will need to be working for at least another year before being qualified to obtain the benefits again.

Like I said I am no actuary, but all things being equal, the monthly 3% to the fund basically means 1 person is covered for every 33 employees. All thing being equal again, in a downturn the Fund should be more than able to carry a 300 basis point jump in unemployment (e.g. if unemployment rate jumps from 3.5% to 6.5%, technically speaking we are better equipped to deal with it. EPF has the database and will be able to verify when a person has found new employment. In any system there will be bad hats trying to find loopholes - heavy penalties should be meted out to discourage bad behaviour by employers and employees.

During good times, the Fund will be able to accumulate surpluses, thus covering the outflows during bad times. It is not meant to be a crutch but part of a developing structure for a developing nation, that seeks to minimise social costs, where we can grow and shoulder the good and bad together. Any major shortfall will be borne by the government, which won't be necessary if the calculations are made properly.

I will send this to Najib as well, I hope he will do something about this. Of course I will not send the photos along with it... hmmm... maybe I should??!!

p/s photos: Meisa Kuroki


Posted by admin
Labels: bankruptcy laws, EPF, unemployment insurance

Report Card On The RM7 Billion


You can get a good idea of the "thinking and strategy" behind the plans being announced, and make an assessment of whether they "know" the problems ahead, have a good appreciation of the problems ahead, and whether they are tackling them with the right medicine. I would rank them from A to E, A being excellent, C being neutral and E being flawed.

The government yesterday cut its economic growth forecast for 2009 to 3.5% from 5.4% and announced several measures to keep the economy ticking, including putting more money in the hands of the people, creating more jobs and boosting the construction and real estate sectors. (A+, The statement show a very sobering and realistic acceptance of the cascading effects from the global financial tsunami. In fact many other countries have only downgraded growth for next year minimally. The 200 basis points downgrade shows a willingness to err on the side of caution, which is good).

Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak, in winding up the debate in parliament on Budget 2009, also gave a commitment that "a big number" of government procurements will, from now, be done via either an open or limited tender process to ensure it gets "value for money". Contracts targeted at bumiputera companies will also be put to competitive bidding among bumiputera firms. Direct negotiations will, however, continue on a discretionary basis. (A, Hard not to be cynical, the words sounded right, will give him benefit of the doubt for 6 months and see if reality mirrors the message. Even a 75% figure for open tender will be a blast).

While the country's fundamentals remained strong, Najib said Malaysia would still be impacted by the current global financial turmoil and economic downturn. This left the government with no choice but to follow other countries and pursue an expansionary fiscal policy to ensure continued economic expansion, albeit at a slower pace. As a result, the government's budget deficit for 2009, originally projected at 3.6%, has been revised to 4.8%, which is the rate anticipated for this year. Inflation, currently running at around 8%, will dip to between 3% and 4% next year, if crude oil price remains at the current level, he said. (A, a responsible statement, and yet aggressive view for a higher budget deficit in 2009. Its fair, committed, responsible tactic without iviting major problems in the future for the country's balance sheet. Whoever is advising najib is doing really well so far).

Najib unveiled an additional RM7.0 billion fiscal stimulus that will be funded by the savings obtained from the recent cut in petrol subsidies. The money will be spent, among others, on:

• RM1.5 billion to set up an Investment Fund to attract more private investments (C, too vague).
• Building RM1.2 billion worth of low- and medium-cost houses (C, good but not good enough. There are plenty of property projects which people have paid deposits but may be in grave danger of being abandoned, look into them as well).
• RM500 million to upgrade police stations, army camps and quarters (C+, smaller construction projects to boost activity, ok la, at least they stayed on the right course by having no mega projects).
• RM600 million to build roads, bridges and community halls in kampungs (B, this is in addition to the latest budget, still better than nothing).
• RM500 million to upgrade schools and hospitals (B, same as above, keep it smallish and spread around the country).

To boost consumer spending, he said employees can opt to cut their contribution to the Employees Provident Fund to 8% from 11% in 2009 and 2010. If all EPF contributors do that, it will free RM4.8 billion a year for them to use (E, reprehensible and irresponsible. Why do you have to boost spending by consumers via their OWN SAVINGS. Already we have a retirement scheme which is really insufficient to care for the MAJORITY of Malaysians. You still want the public to chip in to keep domestic activity going. Its forsaking the future for the present, when the future is already not good enough. The government MUST always regard EPF savings as something sacred and immovable, and must be a very last ditch effort. Once you reduce, it will be very hard to put it back up again. People have to learn to live with a certain mandatory savings rate. If anything, the savings rate should go higher (not at the present time) as the employer and employee contributions should equal 25% sometime within the next 5 years onwards in order for EPF to remain meaningful for Malaysians to retire on).

Najib also said government employees would now enjoy bigger car loans, ranging from RM55,000 to RM70,000 compared with the current RM45,000 to RM60,000. And those with existing housing loans can extend the repayment period to 30 years from 25 years. (C+, while that is good, the government should also think of how these loans would tie down public servants. If the government is intent on improving efficiency and reduce manpower over the next 5 years, such "tie downs" will make it very hard to streamline staffing issues. How to cut 5% of workforce when all of them have these loans dangling everywhere. There are a few firms already extending generous personal loans for government servants only, using direct debit of their salary as paying installments. This instills a mentality that a civil service job is forever. How to improve efficiency properly? These personal loans in addition to their other loans do make their disposable income very tight indeed. You can forecast the compounding ill-effects from this scenario).

Najib also announced steps to boost the construction and property development industry by:
• Removing the import duty for cement and long iron and steel products and exempting the companies from applying for Approved Permits (APs) (B+, I would have given it an A if this WAS MADE PERMANENT. We cannot and should not do things on an adhoc basis, take away now, put back later. It allows for many subsidised industries to always run to the government crying for help whenever the situation does not suit them. All industries, worth having, should learn to compete regionally and globally, or else they don't deserve to exist, we can very well just import from Thailand or Indonesia... just like Singapore. There is really no need to have a steel or cement or auto industry... we are really too small a nation).
• Allowing a foreign individual or entity to buy commercial properties priced above RM500,000 without requiring FIC approval if it is for own use (B+, again, make it permanent, no more flip-flops).

To create jobs, the government through GLCs like Khazanah and PNB will launch a Graduate Employability Management Scheme (GEMS) that will train 12,000 graduates over the next two years (B, has the ability to be really useful, only because Khazanah is involved. Learn to have good spreadsheet skills, pass a basic understanding of accounting, do simple financial modelling, learn how to do power points, improve business English, conducting yourself professionally, learn about priorities and tasks completion scheduling, improve thinking like an entrepreneur and innovator, take up courses to improve your marketability ...).

Stating that the "export-led" strategy used during the 1997/98 crisis cannot be used now because other countries are also slipping into recession, he said the government has to focus on boosting domestic activities. (A, good understanding and good strategy. It would have been too easy and too simplistic to revert to a 4.0 to the USD strategy to export our way out. It would have set our economy back 5-10 years as sunset industries will find more reasons to live, and value add industries will find things hard).

One step to raise revenue and spur domestic economic activity is for the government to maximise returns on its assets, including land that has not been developed, especially those in strategic locations. He cited the Rubber Board land in Sungai Buloh as well as government land in Jalan Cochrane and Ampang Hilir in Kuala Lumpur as examples. Tenders will be opened to private companies and GLCs to develop the parcels of land based on guidelines set by the government. (A, about time, but again everytime you announce such a plan, there will be 2,500 vultures at your door... which would make these plans a D- ... keep it transparent, relevant and open).

If I was on the 4th floor, and they still listens to 4th floor boys ... I would push for:
a) reviving abandoned property projects with capital injections, it will free up capital and improve liquidity in many thousands of property buyers left in the lurch

b) going around and making sure property developers currently selling or building are properly capitalised to avoid any projects being abandoned

c) fast track the removal of import and excise duties on cars to 0% by end of the year, now that will put a lot more cash into people's hands ... AP holders get their money back and current dealers with stock will go through a mediation process to get back a minimal portion of the losses
, or get an export subsidy to send the used cars to other less developed countries
d) implement a gradual removal of oil and gas subsidy for commercial firms, listed and unlisted companies: 50% reduction in subsidy effective Jan 2010, and complete removal on Jan 2012
. Everybody knows how to spend, but we also need to know where to save so that we can spend wisely. Subsidy for commercial firms have to go. The savings will be used more diligently to invest in other value add areas. Need to move up the value chain if everybody is to have higher wages.

p/s photo: Elanne Kong
Posted by admin
Labels: approved permits, economic stimulus, EPF, FIC, Malaysia, Malaysian property

My NS Strategy Advice For Valuecap


The Edge Daily wrote a good piece on Valuecap. Here are the main points:

a) Valuecap Sdn Bhd, the asset management company owned by Khazanah Nasional Bhd, Permodalan Nasional Bhd and the Pensions Trust Fund Council, will receive an injection of RM5 billion to invest in undervalued companies on the Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange. The money, which doubles the size of Valuecap’s capital, is on loan from the Employees Provident Fund (EPF). Valuecap, which was set up in 2002 to add liquidity and volume to the market, has met these objectives.

b) Is Valuecap’s record of its return on investment matches the EPF’s benchmark. However, currently, Valuecap is believed to have about RM4.9 billion worth of investments in 70 companies. And it has been reported that since its inception to September 2007, Valuecap has paid out a total of RM135 million in dividends. Better public disclosure will help to ascertain whether this passes the standard tests for financial performance.

c) A check with the registrar of companies shows that it is in the black and has assets of RM7.5 billion. So Valuecap has some value. But what is the return that EPF will get on the RM5 billion?

d) Since it involves two government-related entities, disclosures must be made every year on the returns. Also, Valuecap should detail the stocks it has in its portfolio just like some of the listed small-cap funds. At the moment, nobody really knows the stocks in Valuecap’s portfolio.

e) The Valuecap story illustrates the importance of transparency in financial reporting to boost investor confidence and the need for clarity about the correct economic stimulus package to move the market sentiments in the right direction.

The blogging community has tried to capture more information on Valuecap's Holdings: copied from http://bursa-chat.blogspot.com/

UAC Bhd 3,222,700 4.33 %

Amway(M) Holdings Bhd 6,958,100 4.23 %

MBM Resources Bhd 10,010,200 4.14 %

Hume Industries Bhd 6,596,400 3.45 %

PPB Group Bhd 40,452,900 3.41 %

IOI Property Bhd 28,267,500 3.4%

KLCC Property Holdings Bhd 30,957,800 3.31 %

Petronas Dagangan Bhd 32,436,400 3.27 %

YTL Cement bhd 14,955,092 3.05 %

Uchi Technologies Bhd 11,318,200 3.03 %

Chintek Plantations Bhd 2,646,000 2.9 %

United Plantations Bhd 5,975,800 2.87 %

Star Publications (M) Bhd 21,148,500 2.86 %

JTI International Bhd 7,144,400 2.73 %

Boustead Properties Bhd 6,672,150 261 %

Bintulu Port Holdings Bhd 10,121,100 2.53 %

Shell Refining Company Bhd 7,589,300 2.53 %

British American Tobacco Bhd 6,505,200 2.28 %

Axis REIT 5,400,000 2.11 %

Quill Capital Trust 4,302,000 1.1%

OSK highlighted 11 potential targets on the Kuala Lumpur Composite Index (KLCI) that Valuecap may go for — MISC, Petronas Gas, DiGi, British American Tobacco, Petronas Dagangan, MAS, Sime Darby, Maybank, IOI, AMMB and MMC.

Comments: From available information, Valuecap performed well. From the list of portfolio companies, it appears that the financial decision making is above-board (i.e. free from being "forced" to invest in "linked or influential" companies). Hence all the more reason to be totally transparent in their undertakings, staffing and investing policies. Its EPF money, hence its the public's money, NOT the government's. If you lend money to someone, you have a right to know how it is going to be spent on.

We also need to know the terms of the agreement between Valuecap and EPF on the disbursement of loan. Are there minimum performance criteria? How are dividends treated or repatriated? What is the time frame for the loan? Can EPF recall the loan at its own discretion, just like EPF can redeem funds mandated to other fund managers. We must have clear arms-length terms. If the government has learnt anything from what the people want over the past 12 months, its more transparency, clarity, stewardship and purpose in policies and management of resources.

In my view, the establishment of Valuecap is OK and justifiable. It is very much in the same platform as HKMA's massive Tracker Fund (although it did not start off as a tracker fund or ETF). When there are massive volatility and imbalances in global capital flows, the establishment of such funds are justifiable and forward looking. You do not want the broader economy to be affected disastrously by such vagaries.

We have to acknowledge that for economies that are highly correlated to fortunes of their own stockmarkets, the establishment of such vehicles are justifiable and proper. Malaysia has one of the highest GDP that is listed among all capital markets. Hence the correlation and flow on effects of the stockmarket is extremely high for the local economy. If that figure is much lower, like many European developed countries, the need to intervene with such vehicles may not be deem as necessary.

My final point is what is the "exit strategy" or "long term strategy" for Valuecap. What happens when you dissolve the fund? You get the same amount of scrips being flooded back into the market. Yes, you can argue that 5 years down the road, when the KLCI is at 1,800 or higher and sentiment has improved, Valuecap may be able to selldown its positions gradually. But that strategy is defeatist in every sense. You will still have to restart another Valuecap the next time a similar situation were to occur in the future - its not a solid strategy.

My advice (and this is worth millions in fees, which I am waiving) is to list Valuecap as an ETF. The strategy should be to break it up into 3 equal tranches. Assuming the portfolio value reaches RM15 billion in a few years time, thats three very sizable ETF. I would recommend to list one in Nasdaq, where the bulk of global ETFs are traded. The other ETF should be listed in Tokyo, while the final one in Malaysia. Do not be blinkered in trying to list all on Bursa on the basis of misplaced pride alone.

The strategy would basically "take the free float" out of the stockmarket, thus ensuring long term sustainability and investing interest. By listing in Tokyo and Nasdaq, you are basically selling all the shares to foreign investors, but the shares do not get back to the market place at all. An ETF will hold the same amount of shares throughout its life, investors will buy and sell the ETF like a share but shares held inside the ETFs would not flow back to the market place.

The strategy basically makes it possible to "trade" Malaysian shares like an index almost 24 hours a day. From Bursa trading hours to US trading hours and then Tokyo trading hours.

Sigh, if I was a Binafikir partner, I would at least get a few million in advisory fees for this.

p/s photo: Christine Mendoza

Posted by admin
Labels: Binafikir, EPF, Khazanah, Malaysia, PNB, Tracker Fund, Valuecap
Older Posts Home
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (312)
    • ▼  June (11)
      • imail (UK Mail) - Winners at the World Mail Awards...
      • Booking.Com - A Cautionary Tale
      • Asset Class Returns As At 31 May 2013
      • US for a Food Delight: A culinary excavation to Am...
      • Wednesday Podcast S&M Show
      • The Fears Of The End Of Quant Easing
      • Air Travel Tips for a Pleasant Vacation
      • Opposite Sex Frienship Revisited: You Cannot Have...
      • A Tribute to Jiah Khan with love AsiansUK
      • My Life's Aphorisms
      • Black Country Asian Business Association 12th Annu...
    • ►  May (52)
    • ►  April (71)
    • ►  March (56)
    • ►  February (55)
    • ►  January (67)
  • ►  2012 (1155)
    • ►  December (44)
    • ►  November (48)
    • ►  October (19)
    • ►  September (24)
    • ►  August (26)
    • ►  July (39)
    • ►  June (31)
    • ►  May (121)
    • ►  April (448)
    • ►  March (209)
    • ►  February (111)
    • ►  January (35)
  • ►  2011 (453)
    • ►  December (33)
    • ►  November (57)
    • ►  October (60)
    • ►  September (36)
    • ►  August (41)
    • ►  July (34)
    • ►  June (26)
    • ►  May (33)
    • ►  April (31)
    • ►  March (49)
    • ►  February (26)
    • ►  January (27)
  • ►  2010 (468)
    • ►  December (33)
    • ►  November (37)
    • ►  October (35)
    • ►  September (32)
    • ►  August (34)
    • ►  July (39)
    • ►  June (38)
    • ►  May (36)
    • ►  April (46)
    • ►  March (55)
    • ►  February (40)
    • ►  January (43)
  • ►  2009 (650)
    • ►  December (42)
    • ►  November (30)
    • ►  October (55)
    • ►  September (50)
    • ►  August (53)
    • ►  July (73)
    • ►  June (67)
    • ►  May (61)
    • ►  April (51)
    • ►  March (62)
    • ►  February (48)
    • ►  January (58)
  • ►  2008 (450)
    • ►  December (43)
    • ►  November (46)
    • ►  October (38)
    • ►  September (46)
    • ►  August (32)
    • ►  July (43)
    • ►  June (45)
    • ►  May (34)
    • ►  April (34)
    • ►  March (28)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (38)
  • ►  2007 (369)
    • ►  December (38)
    • ►  November (26)
    • ►  October (33)
    • ►  September (25)
    • ►  August (35)
    • ►  July (38)
    • ►  June (32)
    • ►  May (36)
    • ►  April (36)
    • ►  March (32)
    • ►  February (19)
    • ►  January (19)
  • ►  2006 (308)
    • ►  December (18)
    • ►  November (18)
    • ►  October (22)
    • ►  September (18)
    • ►  August (27)
    • ►  July (32)
    • ►  June (37)
    • ►  May (35)
    • ►  April (28)
    • ►  March (34)
    • ►  February (26)
    • ►  January (13)
  • ►  2005 (14)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (4)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  May (1)

Total Pageviews

 
My Ping in TotalPing.com