Showing posts with label negative real interest rates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label negative real interest rates. Show all posts

Negative Equity In HK - A Precursor & Benchmark


The number of Hong Kong homeowners in negative equity quadrupled to nearly 11,000 in the last quarter of 2008 as the financial crisis took its toll on property prices. And analysts expect the figure to double this year as property prices fall by a widely expected 10 to 15 percent. Residential mortgage loans in negative equity increased to 10,949 at the end of December from 2,568 at the end of September 2008, according to the Hong Kong Monetary Authority.

What is negative equity: it means the amount you would still be owing after you sell the property and pay off your mortgage. For example, if you bought a house for 600,000 and you borrowed 500,000, which meant that you paid 100,000 as downpayment. Now the house is only worth 450,000 hence your negative equity would be 500,000 - 450,000 = 50,000. Negative equity is 50,000 but in actuality you have already lost 100,000 (downpayment) + 50,000 = 150,000 (not including the many monthly payments may have already made on the property).

HKMA chief executive Joseph Yam Chi-kwong said the increase was anticipated and that it will continue. "But I don't expect the situation will be as bad as in 1998 to 2003. Property prices are tending to remain stable at a certain level," he said.

While the developments are to be expected, what is more important is to see the negative equity figure as a benchmark as a severity of the recession. We must remember that Hong Kong saw a peak of 105,697 negative equity cases in June 2003 amid the SARS outbreak. So 11,000 is still very acceptable. But the the flip side is that the number in negative equity will rise exponentially and very swiftly if property prices were to slide in greater quantum for the next 6 months. Possibly another 10% slide in price would bring the negative equity figures close to the 2003 SARS level.

Pan Asian Mortgage Advisory economist Alvin Ho predicts the number of negative-equity homeowners will increase to more than 20,000 this year if property prices continue to decline. Real estate prices in the secondary market dropped 20 percent to an average of HK$3,410 per square foot in the fourth quarter from last year's peak of HK$4,251 psf, according to Midland Realty. The HKMA said the aggregate value of mortgages in negative equity rose 313 percent to HK$24.8 billion in the fourth quarter from the previous quarter. The unsecured portion of these loans rose to HK$2.7 billion. The loan-to- value ratio of the loans increased to 112 percent from 107 percent. The three-month delinquency ratio of negative equity mortgages fell to 0.05 percent from 0.08 percent.

Meanwhile, Yam said companies in Hong Kong have more than HK$100 billion in syndicated loans that are due to expire this year. The HKMA will take appropriate action and "the government should keep an open mind" to help financing, he said. "Foreign banks based in Europe and America may have to handle their own problems at headquarters by deleveraging. Their foreign business will then be affected." However, Chinese University associate finance professor Raymond So Wai-man warned that the government will come "under great pressure if it helps companies refinance debt."

Yam said there is a risk that protectionism could spread from trade to finance. As an example, countries are no longer buying US Treasury bonds. The HKMA intends to cancel its temporary provision of additional funds to banks at the end of March but will review the facility at that time to decide if it needs to be extended.

Amidst all the planning and forecasting, HK should remember that its monetary policy, property price and hence stock market are tied to their currency peg. The USD has been injected with a huge array of new "fundamentals" over the last 6 months - HKMA should really reconsider the HK dolar peg because the "integrity, outlook and volatility of the USD" going forward will be more like a horror movie. You cannot have your currency tied to highly risky, highly indefensible monetary expansionary policies somewhere else... the USD by virtue of their actions over the last 6 months have basically sentenced the dollar to a long drawn out period of weakness and losing stature as a reserve currency.


HK Property Confidential



  • Hong Kong's home sales fell 58% y/y in volume and 63% in value transacted in October as local lenders tightened mortgage lending amid a slowdown in the economy - this is the largest drop since 1999 and the fourth consecutive monthly decline. Bank lending rose 13% in September, the slowest in over a year, and almost half the 24% increase in August. Office rents in Hong Kong may experience a 20% drop by the end of 2009.
  • Banks have not lowered their prime rates along with the 0.5% cut in the US interest rate and are adopting more conservative mortgage lending policies (loaning less and scrutinizing borrowers more).
  • Prices have been sticky downwards in HK (even stickier in Malaysia as many sellers are waiting for firmer prices with arrogance) as many home-owners have only just
    woken up to the fact that the market is heading into a protracted downturn as
    opposed to a brief correction. Average prices have only fallen 14% from the peak (Prices have already fallen 14% in HK and probably the same in Singapore... in Malaysia, it has not budged much yet... watch for first out best dressed action soon..). The high-end segment is still outperforming and faces more downside risk. home-buyers may be canceling transactions by forfeiting the deposits and delaying completion date of the transactions.Equity prices remain above their historical lows.
  • Citigroup: downward spiral in the Hong Kong property market will continue for the next 12 months - potential push back in completions and the lack of new land sales by the government will result in further declines in construction activities, leading to rising unemployment in the sector, and deal a further blow to the economy (through other industries like property agency, interior decorations, furniture and fittings, consumer electronics) which in turn will adversely affect housing demand.
  • Hong Kong's prime office rents surged 33% in the 12 months ended May 2008 (Colliers) but most assume that their growth will slow over the next year
  • During the 2nd quarter of 2008, prices fell in several segments of Hong Kong’s property market. Smaller sized apartments were especially hit badly but property prices were strongly up over the year. The overall index rose 25.4% (19.4% in real terms) to end Q2 2008.
  • Strong consumption growth has been propelling residential and commercial property prices upward while negative real interest rates have been supporting the creation of new development.Robust labor market has kept demand for commercial space tight (PREI) But with credit costs rising and slowing economic growth, Hong Kong's property market could be vulnerable.
  • PREI: total housing transaction value in the second quarter fell by 4.6% from that of a year before.
  • Decline in global shipping on higher costs/slower demand for raw materials might have negative effect on warehousing demand which has been a driver of retail property demand.
  • Jones Lasalle: despite slowing consumption growth, leasing costs have been rising. Sales volumes have fallen but so far prices are holding up so far (through mid Q3).
  • Residential property prices were accelerating early in 2008, from 10.1% yoy increase in June 2007 to 27.7% in January 2008. Prices at the luxury end of the market are already back at 1997 levels. Low borrowing cost at 2.5%, high property yields at 4%-5% made property investment more attractive.
p/s photos: Fala Chen Fat Lai (Men love fast powerful cars like Lambros, Ferraris, Aston Martins and Porsches... not because they really appreciate the engine specs and mechanics... but because they have never seen an ugly woman get out of one)