Showing posts with label rita rudani. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rita rudani. Show all posts

Landmarks Is About To Take Off


If you were trading MAA, you'd better be having balls of steel. The oil and gas counters have been hogging the limelight and looks to be needing a pause. Certain developments over the past week made me look at Landmark as being very ripe for a massive re-rating upwards. Some background first.

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhZX4AQyreW9WsJE_3riXN7dhmXADScaOsfa-dtJp1LSVTM8KgpYHZLZFfZUXbGuWb_TXWd90d8uEYhheUtF2PEBchb3AB17jPVuafiwfKPsroYohgx9ua1MrYz9sS85yMAYblzivQZV84/s1600/rita+rudaini+manis.jpg

The transformation - Landmarks Berhad (LB) undertook a massive transformation in 2006‐2008, selling off non‐core, non‐strategic and matured businesses as well as entities in which it had no management control. The disposals of these assets, including retail malls, hotels, healthcare service providers and independent power producers, raised total cash proceeds of RM876m, net of loan repayments.

LB has only 3 major assets. Of its original assets, only The Andaman Langkawi resort hotel (net book value: RM117m, revalued in 2008) and MSL Properties Sdn Bhd (20%+1 share, carrying value: RM43m, township developer in Wangsa Maju) were retained after the disposals. The third and biggest asset is its 100% stake in Bintan Treasure Bay Pte Ltd (BTB), the developer of Treasure Bay Bintan, which it bought for RM771m in 3 tranches between May 2007 and May 2008. The acquisition was in line with its vision to be a leading player in the lifestyle sector focusing on resorts, hospitality and wellness in South East Asia.

Table 1: Disposals & acquisitions under transformation programme (RMm)
A. Disposals 915
Sep‐05 50% MSL Properties Sdn Bhd (property developer) 78
Feb‐06 60% Qualitas Healthcare Corporation 10
Sep‐06 70% Mediscreen Sdn Bhd 4
Apr‐07 Sungei Wang Plaza retail mall 285
Sep‐07 26% Shangri‐la Hotels (Malaysia) Berhad 287
Nov‐07 Datai Langkawi Hotel 72
May‐08 20% Teknologi Tenaga Perlis Consortium (independent power producer) 179
B. Acquisitions 771
May‐07 64.5% of Bintan Treasure Bay Pte Ltd 353
Nov‐07 9.5% of Bintan Treasure Bay Pte Ltd 54
May‐08 26% of Bintan Treasure Bay Pte Ltd 365

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgkFuYzDXDZMmqmebZ8klNjj6goujI9sed-7xzpaaLG-SugtMGswv-P6q3cRah4xxkGJpIlIFdEudRx8xuh1HzUzmSDKqqlMZpdvYdtzDhfZFWaEgVZqGy9TJvRbnOB7Fo-HwMLM9jujHA/s400/rita.jpg

Crown jewel is its 338‐ha land in Bintan Island. LB’s crown jewel is the 338‐ha land in Bintan Island strategically located next to Bintan Bandar Telani Ferry Terminal, the main gateway to Bintan from Singapore (45 minutes by ferry). The land will be developed into an integrated health, leisure, cultural, residential and commercial real estate paradise, and supported by world‐class infrastructure. BTB signed an agreement with PT Wisata Hiburia (an Indonesian entity that has been granted a Decree for Permanent License of International Exclusive Integrated Tourism by Regent of Kabupaten Bintan) on 24 Jan 2008 for the zoning of Treasure Bay Bintan as an Exclusive Integrated Tourism Zone for conducting certain licensed activities ‐ medical tourism; multimedia & information technology hosting; and games & entertainment (including gaming).

The other side of the coin is Gallant Ventures, a company listed on SGX. Gallant Ventures Ltd, the developer of the 1300‐ha Lagoi Bay Development in Bintan, sold commercial, resort and residential land plots at S$312, S$119 and S$300 psm respectively. The preparation of the master plan is still in progress, LB hopes to launch Bintan Treasure Bay development in early 2011.





The 338‐ha land in Bintan Island, held by wholly‐owned Bintan Treasure Bay Pte Ltd (BTB), was last revalued at S$242 psm in 2008 by an independent valuer, 144% higher than LB’s entry cost of S$99 psm. LB trades at a massive 70% discount to book NTA, which is at the high end of discounts amongst property companies.

Gallant Ventures Ltd, the developer of 1300‐ha Lagoi Bay Development in Bintan, saw its shares rising enormously last week. LB, on the other hand, currently trades at price/NTA of 0.45x, and book NTA of RM3.54. Shares of Gallant Ventures, which develops industrial parks and resorts in Indonesia's Bintan and Batam, rose as much as 16.5 percent a couple of days ago after DBS Vickers resumed its coverage on the stock with a buy call and S$0.88 target price. At midday, Gallant Venture shares were up 14.1 percent at S$0.485 on a volume of nearly 100 million shares, around 9 times the average volume in the last 30 days. All things being equal, LB should be marking time to get to RM2.00 easily. Its not just a rule of thumb, but rather, they are like Siamese twins. Just look at the correlation of the two share prices over the past 2 years - uncanny. They track each other almost to over 90%.

The DBS research caused a huge interest in Gallant Ventures, gaping up considerably. Since its DBS, I do expect a similar hefty report on LB to be coming out very very soon. Surprising not many investors have spotted this. The shares moved up nicely on Friday indicating that I am not the only one spotting this anomaly. Ways to go. (Landmarks white line, Gallant Ventures orange line).

https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=7b83c92ec4&view=att&th=12f335c5e775cb04&attid=0.2&disp=inline&realattid=f_gm8lvmf21&zw

Let's look at the DBS research piece, issued on 6 April 2011 as what applies to Gallant Ventures will only mean the same (and more) for LM. DBS research target price is S$0.88 compared to its price when the report was issued at S$0.43. The shares rose and rose to close at S$0.495 on 45m shares traded yesterday.

DBS Research - Prime Lagoi Bay development to take flight. Gallant Venture (“GV”), a master developer of industrial parks and resorts in Bintan and Batam, owns over 18,000 ha undeveloped landbank on Bintan island held at its historical cost of S$0.78 – S$10.95psm. Development of its prime site - Lagoi Bay, a 1,505-ha sea-facing site is taking shape, with major infrastructure works and construction of the central shopping mall is in advanced stages. The group booked in S$33m sales with over 70% margins as it transferred the first land packets to investors. We believe the development of Lagoi Bay as an integrated resort will spur much investors’ interest and land sales in the future.

Re-initiate BUY with SOTP-based TP of S$0.88. Gallant Venture will unlock substantial value from more land sales sparked by the Lagoi Bay development, where the group has and is projected to sell its plots at an average of cS$120psm, against expected development cost of cS$35 psm and substantial windfall gains from its opportunistic investment projects. Our SOTP-based TP of S$0.88 offers over than 100% upside.

Why it did not take off previously? While Bintan offers one of the nicest beaches in South East Asia, the longer term vision of the island turning into a major regional resort enclave off the shores of Singapore did not take off as expected as (i) the haphazard development of existing resorts in our view - with individual developers and operators scattered unevenly across the island created a “bubble effect” amongst tourists who rarely venture out of the respective resorts, (ii) accessibility between the resorts is both limited and deliberately stunted as a lack of centralised public attractions such as Patong Beach in Phuket for tourists to explore and mingle and a lack of vibrancy and attractiveness of the island as visitors stay and play only within the boundaries of their resorts, (iii) the lack of alternative transportation, where the only entry into Bintan is through Ferry has limited the growth of visitor arrivals into the island.

Upcoming Lagoi Bay Development to inject vibrancy and life into Bintan – a key to complete Bintan’s puzzle. In order to fully realise Bintan’s potential, Gallant Venture plans to integrate the current self-sustaining resorts with a masterplanned village centre located at the heart of Lagoi Bay to draw in the crowds and add further variety to the current attractions on the island. Gallant Venture’s vision is for the Beach Village (“LBV”) to draw the disparate pieces of Bintan’s disorganised development together and transform them into a vibrant and self-sustaining community.

Unlocking value process starts. Development of its prime site - Lagoi Bay, a 1,505-ha sea-facing site is taking shape, with major infrastructure works and construction of the central shopping mall in advanced stages. The group booked in S$33m sales at an average price of S$100-150 psm, enabled the group to record over 70% margins as it transferred the first land packets to investors to start development of the various land plots into resorts/resort homes. We believe the development of Lagoi Bay as an integrated resort will spur much investors interests and land sales in the future.

Treasure Bay – Landmarks’ S$425m project next to Gallant’s Lagoi Bay site expected to raise international visibility for BIntan. Landmarks Berhad recently launched phase 1 of its Treasure Bay resort island site and is pumping more than S$425m into development of a resort covering over 222 acres. Featuring a luxury resort and serviced villas, a dedicated multi model transportation terminal, world class marina and lagoon, as well as amenities for entertainment, retail, night-life and F&B, the project is expected to complete in 2015. The launch of a big-name project such as Treasure Bay will definitely raise the profile of Bintan Island and a big boost for Gallant Venture. Developers and potential investors alike will watch Treasure Bay’s development closely.

Going forward, looking to ease mode of transport into Bintan. Gallant Venture proposal of moving its current embarkation point from Tanah Merah Ferry Terminal (TMFT) to the upcoming Marina South Ferry Terminal downtown when completed by end 2011 is in the works as the the shift will be positive for Bintan’s image as a travel destination and weekendplayground for Singaporeans, as it will cut the ferry journey down to c30-45min and eliminate the need for tourists to travel to the relatively obscure Tanah Merah Ferry Terminal (next to Changi Airport, in the Eastern part of Singapore).

In addition, a proposed new airport is in the works with President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono granting permission for a new airport (catering from single- aisled planes like Boeing 737s and Airbus 320s) to be built at the Lobam industrial area, 35min away from Bintan Resorts. We understand that Gallant Venture will be involved and is currently looking for partners to embark on this plan to build an airport. This new embarkation point will be a key catalyst to the further growth in the tourism sector of Bintan in the longer term.

LB is a cheaper proxy to rising land prices in Bintan, the gateway to the Riau Archipelago. The share price is even below Genting Berhad’s book cost of RM2.37 per share. Landmarks is trading at a hefty discount of more than 70% to our estimated RNAV of RM4.81. It also boasts RM130m net cash, which works out to RM0.27/share or 20% of the current share price.

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjF_RPSAswMzJzbUnQ99alqjylwu3hvP8pMZ4CvMoVg5Otpvq5btzc6Bh8KVDmgoK4oZKLSv5pSCcwdxNXRY3IR0W69Qh-5Xqa1HBPozq-eUvIQPffMxGp8dKH-1VEa1rd2GSTWapZrE0jw/s1600/20765_245841306834_245838256834_3788228_302620_n.jpg

This may have been missed by many investors:

PULAU BINTAN (Indonesia) Feb 26 (Bernama) -- Indonesian President, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, today launched Landmarks Bhd''s water city resort in Teluk Sebung, Pulau Bintan, one of the islands in the Riau archipelago. The integrated project includes a hotel, marine terminal, marine aircraft terminal, marina, shops, amusement parks and other facilities. Susilo named the integrated tourist resort "Pesona Lagoi Bintang" (Lagoi Bintang Charm).

In his speech, the president, who was accompanied by his wife, Ibu Ani Yudhoyono, said he hoped Pulau Bintan would be developed to become a well-known integrated tourist centre in the region like Singapore''s.
"We do not wish to see only Singapore becomes developed, we want to grow together. Pulau Bintan has more to offer compare to Singapore in terms of nature," he said.
On the Hollywood movie, ''Eat, Pray, Love'', he said ideally, the film should be shot in Bintan.
"They don''t have to go to Italy to eat, India to pray and Bali to fall in love. Bintan can offer them all," he said.
Susilo also questioned Singapore''s promotion ''Visit Singapore Then Bintan. Bintan can become well-known and promote itself like ''Visit Bintan Then Singapore''.
The water city resort, which covers 338 hectares, is called ''Treasure Bay''. It will be developed by Landmarks unit, Bintan Treasure Bay Pte Ltd, over 20 years.
Its chief operating officer, Paul Leong, said the first phase of the project, which would include the building of international standard marine, multi-modal terminal and entertainment facilities and restaurant, would cost S$425 million.

Catalysts:

a) One is the launch of the group’s core asset, the 835-acre Treasure Bay Bintan (TBB)development. When things are moving, like they have been for the past 2 months, the realisation will somehow dawn upon investors that the projects are starting and no longer just a pipe dream - expect both counters' huge discounts to RNAV will narrow dramatically.

b) Two, the announcement of gaming operations at the TBB resort, which would be a huge catalyst for the stock. Still an if, but a very big if. Even if it does not eventuate, the redevelopment of Bintan will still yield sufficient profits for the big early players. Singaporeans just love land near and far, they need new properties to buy, I guess.

c) The positive re-rating of its Siamese twin, Gallant Ventures.


Assuming a 50% discount to its RNAV, the stock could trade at RM2.41. Landmarks could also ride on the 40% share price rally of Gallant in recent weeks.

The mixed development project which has an estimated GDV of S$1.8bn (RM4.3bn) is expected to comprise of resorts, condominiums and villas. Plans call for its development as the Water Resort City of Bintan with canals, waterways and lakes. It will target the middle- to upper-segment of tourists and investors, particularly Indonesians and Singaporeans. Tourist arrivals in Bintan reached 410,000 in 2009 and are projected to touch 440,000 in 2010. Most of the tourists come from Singapore.

No confirmation of gaming business yet? Landmarks did not confirm whether there are plans to set up a gaming establishment there. In Jan 08, the company announced the signing of a zoning agreement between BTB and PT Wisata Hiburia (PTWH).

What is the zoning about? The zoning involved the designation of Treasure Bay Bintan as an exclusive integrated tourism zone (EITZ) for conducting certain licensed activities i) medical tourism, ii) multimedia and information technology hosting, and iii) games and entertainment, including gaming. PTWH has been granted a surat izin tetap usaha wisata internasional terpadu eksklusif (decree for permanent licence of international exclusive integrated tourism) by the Bupati of Kabupaten Kepulauan Riau which allows PTWH to zone land in Bintan Island where the above-mentioned activities can be conducted. Of course there are undoubtedly risks associated with the licence to operate a gaming establishment on Bintan as gaming is still prohibited in Indonesia. Even without the gaming facility, Bintan should be sustainable for the landed projects they have in mind.

Due to the 2008 global financial crisis, the Treasure Bay Bintan project was put on hold. However, the company recently indicated that it is resuming the project and is finalising a master plan for the project.

Lastly, at present price up to RM1.80, getting into Landmarks is already lower than Genting's entry price. There are so many levels of comfort here: cash is 20% of share price; deep 70% discount to RNAV; following the immense success of Sentosa and the huge potential of Iskandar, it would be very silly for Yudhoyono not to work to have Indonesia getting a proper representation using Bintan as part of the "triangle of too-much-money-for-redevelopment, the triangle of the new Monaco/Macau, the triangle of dreams and visions" ... which is why I believe Indonesia will make Bintan IR a special zone to allow casinos there eventually in order to compete properly within the triangle.

NOTE: The above opinion is not an invitation to buy or sell. It serves as a blogging activity of my investing thoughts and ideas, this does not represent an investment advisory service as I charge no subscription or management fees (donations are welcomed though). I may have a position in the counter already. The content on this site is provided as general information only and should not be taken as investment advice. All site content, shall not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell any security or financial instrument. The ideas expressed are solely the opinions of the author. Any action that you take as a result of information, analysis, or commentary on this site is ultimately your responsibility. Consult your investment adviser before making any investment decisions.

http://images.travelpod.com/tripwow/photos/ta-00e9-960e-5322/rita-rudaini-malaysia-malaysia+1152_12980418863-tpfil02aw-6254.jpg

Short Selling, Securities Lending - The Prequel, The Sequel & Then Some More


Well after two and a half year of screwing around, we are back at the table on Short Selling. Only this time, the "leadership" seems to have been taken over by Securities Commission instead of Bursa ... hmmm... wonder why??!! ; ) I searched through my older posts on Restricted Short Selling and its funny how the tone of my postings have changed (or mellowed rather). I was so much more vicious and angrier then... ; ) ... Let's look at the history for a while:

------

as posted on 11th October 2006 ...


Regulated Short Selling Will Fail Dismally (Again)

Bursa will not like to hear me on this. They'd probably think I have a deep vendetta against them. First, Bursa is too greedy to try and act as the Central Lending Agency. Brokers, custodians and investors all have to go through Bursa to things done. This creates an unnecessary layer which adds to cost.
Secondly, Bursa failed to appreciate why an OTC market would have been better. Not all lenders want to lend shares at 2%, some may only lend at 5% or even 10%. Take Google shares for example, at US$500, probably a lot of people would want to short it, hence the lenders could actually ask for a higher rate before lending out. A transparent and free-market OTC makes for real activity and better returns for both sides. I am not sure if Bursa even have the mechanism to change the lending rates?? (..what, change the rates... every now and then ... so much work la...). Thirdly, too much red tape, inteference, scrutiny... blah blah... Having said that, as long as people can make big money, they can withstand the trouble to invest, if they can make 30% in a month in Timbuktu exchange, you can betcha they will try to get there. But it probably won't happen in Bursa's RSS - limited shares for shorting, do you think there will be 1 million of a company's shares for shorting? Chances are, it will be sporadic and insignificant, which will turn people off. That is why an OTC would have stood a better chance to survive. Imagine the current scenario, with Genting jumping on the Macau news, I think its a good time to short Genting shares, but no one wants to lend at 2%, so I put up a willingness to borrow 50,000 shares at 4% or even 6%, I am sure someone will bite. The failure to allow for a free flowing capital markets. The shallow thinking that by being the Central Lending Agency, somehow that could prevent disasters needs to be re-examined. You mean, the 1997 implosion was due to short sellers??? Please grow up, that shows how naive the current crop of people in unthinkably high positions are... sigh... You cannot molly-coddle a capital market, it has to be relatively laissez-faire ... look at global best practices... please...

p/s btw, I totally agree there should be short selling, just do it better ... man...

------

as posted on July 17, 2008 ....


RSS (restricted short selling)... it was expected to fail, it failed ... NO SHARES AVAILABLE FOR SHORTING!!! What does that tell you about the program? A learned friend disagreed with my negative assessment on RSS two years ago saying they have international consultants and exchanges helping on the product. Just because they are foreign, does not mean they are good. The Bursa is ladened with bureaucracy, red tape, nothing ever gets decided, in the end any decision will take two months to make, and the bulk of people never really touch securities before...

-----

Now to the present, the SC obviously said something to the effect of "I don't think you guys really know what you are doing" to Bursa... Anyway, why make more enemies? My comments in red.

Aug 4 (Bernama) — The Securities Commission (SC) and Bursa Malaysia today announced the introduction of securities borrowing and lending negotiated transaction (SBLNT), an enhanced securities borrowing and lending (SBL) model that offers an option to borrow and lend on an over-the-counter (OTC) basis. In a joint statement here today, the SC and Bursa Malaysia said the SBLNT model would be implemented on August 17 and relevant participants would be able to submit applications now.

They said the model would complement the existing SBL Central Lending Agency (SBL CLA) model which was introduced in January 2007 as the first phase of the securities borrowing and lending framework. ( Gee, this is b.s., what do you mean by "complement", it complements nothing, the existing SBL is crapufullacrap, obviously somebody devised a "better way to not lose face" by using the word "complement", just say it like it is... it IS a new way to replace the previous crap).

“Under the SBLNT framework, any eligible person who is approved by Bursa Malaysia Securities Clearing Sdn Bhd may borrow and lend securities. The lender and borrower are now given the flexibility to enter into SBL agreements, hence they can negotiate and agree on the terms of borrowing and lending directly,” they said.

These SBL transactions, they said, must be reported via onshore borrowing and lending representatives and facilitated through Bursa Malaysia Securities Clearing as the approved clearing house.

“This reporting is imperative for the movement of the loaned securities to take effect from the lender’s depository account to the borrower’s depository account. In addition, only securities that are specified by the approved clearing house are eligible for borrowing and lending transactions and the purposes for which the borrowing and lending have also been specified,” they said.

The statement said the SBLNT framework would also enable Bursa Malaysia Securities Clearing to ensure orderly and transparent borrowing and lending. Besides that, the SC also released the revised SBL Guidelines while Bursa Malaysia issued the relevant rules, procedures and guidelines to provide for SBLNT. (All things being equal, transparency is good, but in such a small market such as the Bursa, with an even smaller number of "players", the transparency rule actually inhibits, scares and restricts the players. A better rule would be, as long as the investor is "approved and has an account with an approved broker", if client borrows or lends, it should be referred to by a number, and not the actual client. The unique structure of short selling/ lending give rise to excessive spotlight and focus on these transactions - no clients will want to be shamed publicly by its fraternity for having shorted at the wrong levels or lent securities which have since collapsed in price.)

In the SBL CLA model, Bursa Malaysia Securities Clearing acts as the central lending agency for all SBL activities conducted in Malaysia and participants need to comply with the terms and conditions as directed by Bursa Malaysia Securities Clearing.

Both the current SBL CLA and the new SBLNT models will operate concurrently. The revised SBL Guidelines by SC also provide clarification on the tax treatment applicable to SBLNT. The revised SBL Guidelines and rules are available on the SC website at www.sc.com.my as well as Bursa Malaysia website at www.bursamalaysia.com.

-----
My Worthless Views: It is a better model in that it allows for negotiated terms of borrowing or lending. However, it will fail just as dismally as the earlier model because:

a) The model still requires investors to borrow the securities first before selling. In many places, the investor has the option of selling the shares first, and then having 3 days (in the US) to borrow the shares. Naturally that is risky as one might not be able to borrow the shares, but herein lies the shortcoming, there isn't sufficient liquidity on the lending side here. Chicken and egg thingy, no liquidity, smaller share caps, low free float ratios, and you cannot sell first then borrow later which is an important option.


b) The vast majority of stocks borrowed by brokers (in most markets) come from loans made by the leading custody banks and fund management companies. Depending on specific account agreements, brokers are able to borrow stocks from their customers who own "long" positions, particularly those in "margin" accounts. I don't think our custody banks and fund management companies are "up to speed" with the nature and benefits of short-selling. I don't think many of the trust deed of local fund management companies even allow them to do that.


c) It isn't clear to the borrowers that the lenders may ask for the return of shares, and the borrower will have to return them to the lender or borrow the shares from elsewhere. Its cumbersome and most participants are not savvy or patient enough to go through all the trouble.
A successful short selling model requires a critical mass of institutional players, which we do not have. We need hedge funds players, we need astute local funds that trade and hedge, we need a lot of local funds that are willing to lend securities, we need... (fill in the blanks).

d) The only savvy short selling / lending players are the local brokers. Right now MOST LOCAL BROKERS are "lending shares" to cover short positions, many without even telling their clients - its a loophole the SC and Bursa must plug. My strong recommendation is for all brokers be required to get "expressed permission of the customer" before they can "deploy or lend" the securities belonging to the clients, and that the clients must be properly compensated for it.



p/s photos: Rita Rudani

Sovereign Wealth Funds Are Generally Sheeps In Wolves' Clothing


Just how have the track record been for sovereign wealth funds. Temasek and GIC were path leaders for the most of last 10 years with their aggressive investing strategies. The Gulf nations SWFs only started to adopt Singapore's aggressive tactics over the last 5 years - joining in at the wrong end of the trend.

Let the record show that when these fund outperform, its largely due to momentum and bull market rallies, rather than astute stock picking. The bulk of the gains were made from telco investing in Asia, banking investing in Asia, followed by the disastrous banking investing in developed nations. For most of the last 10 years, there had been a sharp demand to bid up telco assets in emerging nations as growth prospects struggled in developed countries, thus the higher prices. Same can be said for banking stakes in emerging countries. Temasek, thanks to its connections, got in early acquiring substantial stakes in Chinese banks before they were floated. Take that factor out and you would have seen Temasek figures down the drain, literally.

The Gulf nations SWF, thanks to the surge in petrodollars over the last few years, looked to acquire significant Western assets in exchange for the petrodollars in order to make the money work for them in the future. Alas! What it did was to give back the supernormal gains to the very people who bought the oil at silly prices in the first place.

So, what went wrong? Are SWFs incapable of investing wisely? Firstly, their size makes their strategy limited. They certainly won't be considering investments that have a market cap of less than $250m, because if they do, they would be looking at a portfolio of well over hundreds of companies, how to monitor - attend board meetings also die.

Secondly, they want a substantive stake, not so much to have board seats or board control, but that to be able to influence management somewhat, to be consulted over major investing and capital decisions.

Thirdly, they tend to overpay - when you have identified a good sector or a good company, the sellers will also know its SWFs who are behind the deal, the general feeling is that they will be willing to pay a premium to get that substantial stake because they do not come around too often.

Fourthly, SWFs never seem to "walk through the data and financials" - I have mentioned this before, maybe its the fact that they are always suited up in nice executive dressing, they don't do enough "dirty work" before going ahead with a purchase or disposal. Figures and research reports are all there, and if you stop there, you risk a lot in your investments especially when we are talking about billions of dollars and a substantial stake. Its easy to talk to management, but you need to walk through the financials with a fine comb - go behind the aggregation of data, the assumptions, talk to the mid level managers and their competitors and suppliers, check with their clients, see how satisfied they are, if its a bank thats been showing tremendous growth in certain units, verify why and how that came about, go through the processes that made they stand apart from the competition. If things look too good to be true, all the more reason to look deeper.

That to me are all the main reasons why SWFs are sheeps in wolves' clothing. SWFs need to get away from pure trend investing. They need to think clearly whether to buy something for solid dividend yield protection or organic growth or growth via acquisitions. They need to think 5 years or 10 years out, which sectors would be a lot more lucrative then - I don't think telcos would be, banks would be iffy still, but commodities and food would be great. Its really simple in the end, it when you have too many suits in the room, thats what causes problems.

------------------------------


Sovereign wealth funds (SWFs) were much in the news last year. As the first wave of the financial crisis hit, Gulf and Asian funds such as the Kuwait Investment Authority (KIA) and Singapore’s Temasek, ploughed billions of dollars into recapitalising prominent Wall Street institutions such as Merrill Lynch and Citigroup. At the time, with oil riding high at more than US$100 a barrel, it seemed very much as if the balance of economic power was shifting rapidly eastward. Despite the fact that their combined value accounted for only a fraction of the size of other investor classes such as pension funds or insurers, there was a brief moment when sovereign wealth was seen by some western politicians as a considerable threat to their economic independence.

The steady steamroller of the global crunch has seen those fears substantially recede. A collapse in demand from manufacturing powerhouses such as China led to a slump in the price of oil last autumn, a downwards journey aided by the exit of speculators. Furthermore, as soon as it became apparent that the instability which began in financial institutions had infected other sectors of the economy, the size of the necessary fiscal response dwarfed the capacity of anything other than a government-led rescue. With the exception of Daimler, which received a $2.7 billion (Dh9.91bn) capital injection by selling a 9.1 per cent stake to Abu Dhabi’s Aabar Investments in March, none of the recent major corporate bailouts has seen sovereign wealth riding the white horse.

As if to confirm the retreat of sovereign wealth from the basic international economic agenda, no mention of it was made in the concluding statement at the end of the Group of 20 (G20) summit of leading and emerging economies in London last month. According to German government sources, the omission was intentional.

SWFs may no longer be in the spotlight but they have not gone away; moreover, the chain of events established by last year’s backlash against sovereign wealth continues to play out. Following a degree of pressure from the US Congress and the EU, an International Working Group (IWG) of SWFs was established last October, under the auspices of the IMF. This group, which includes fund-holders such as the UAE as well as concerned inbound nations such as the US, published a series of investment guidelines called the “Generally Accepted Principles and Practices” (GAPP) – better known as the Santiago Principles after the city in which they were drawn up. The principles call for SWF investments to be based on “economic and financial grounds”, and if not, for the alternative rationale to be clearly stated.


The wording of the accompanying statement to the principles claims they are intended to ensure transparency and accountability. Yet the decision to call the document a “voluntary code of principles”, as opposed to a more binding code of conduct, is telling. According to Dr Sven Behrendt of the Carnegie Middle East Centre, a specialist in SWFs, the Santiago Principles “enable signatories to adhere to a standard, but without any monitoring or enforcement mechanisms”. The result is what Dr Behrendt calls an “unsecure document” – an agreement which is not yet sufficient to prevent unilateral action further down the line from concerned governments of nations receiving inbound investments, if and when SWFs become a political issue once more.

While the Santiago Principles may, thus far, fall short of providing countries such as the US with the guarantees they would like, according to Dr Behrendt the procedure involved to agree upon them marks an innovative concept in global governance. “The IWG reflects a bottom-up approach towards regulation, and is one of the rare occasions when industrial and industrialising nations have come together on an equal footing to agree on a set of principles”, he says. The contrast between the IWG and, for example, the Group of Seven (G7) or the Doha round of world trade talks is stark. Like SWFs themselves, the IWG represents an element of structural transition in the global economic system – one whereby the traditional power centres of the West are having to make room at the table for the growing financial clout of the East – a trend notably repeated at the G20 summit.

As if to confirm the permanence of this structural transition, the IWG is itself evolving into a permanent institution. Following the conclusion of its fourth meeting in Kuwait last month, the body announced it would form a permanent representative forum, with a secretariat to be staffed by the IMF. The forum will be chaired by David Murray, the head of Australia’s Future Fund Board of Guardians, while Bader al Sa’ad of the KIA and Jin Liqun of the China Investment Corporation will serve as deputy chairmen. Its first meeting is planned to be held in Baku this October.

If early 2008 marked the high-water point of sovereign wealth in the media eye, what will be its ultimate long-term significance as a structural element in the global financial system? For example, does it represent as fundamental a shift in the balance of power as the creation of OPEC in the 1970s?

Dr Behrendt presents three possible scenarios: first – and most pessimistic – oil prices remain so severe that funds are forced to liquidate their assets to inject liquidity domestically. This scenario would in effect mark the end of sovereign wealth as a market phenomenon. The second possibility is that SWFs remain essentially where they are, as smaller players compared with pension funds, but with the potential to create the occasional headline in sensitive markets. In this case, the permanent forum will be of most importance as a capacity building institution for the less-experienced SWFs.

The third possibility, however, is that economic recovery, and especially a recovery in the demand for commodities, results in SWFs becoming “super strong”. It is in this final scenario where the Santiago Principles, and the permanent forum, will play a significant role in reconciling the concerns of inbound nations with the demands of investors. As it currently stands, achieving such a role still requires a considerable amount of work.

Oliver Cornock is regional editor of the Oxford Business Group


p/s photo: Rita Rudani