Showing posts with label meisa kuroki. Show all posts
Showing posts with label meisa kuroki. Show all posts

Fiscal Cliff Averted, China Good News, Even From North Korea ... Rally Baby!!!


Shares everywhere is set to start the year on a positive note after a tentative deal to avert the "fiscal cliff" in the US and encouraging economic news from China.

Dow Jones futures were 250 points higher - about 2 per cent - after the deal was agreed in a late-night meetings in Congress, setting the scene for a good start to the trading year. The Dow Jones Industrial Average had closed 166.03 points higher at 13,104.14 on Monday after signs of a possible deal.

The ''fiscal cliff'', which was set to kick in on January 1, would have led to $US600 billion of tax increases and spending cuts. It's important to remember that there's some tightening of fiscal policy, which is good news - that's what the US economy needs given its budget position - but it's not so severe as to cause a hard landing. The elimination of a 2 percent payroll tax cut, coupled with higher income taxes on the wealthy, will help reduce growth in the first quarter to 1 percent, from 3.1 percent in 2012’s third quarter, the latest data available. The expected slowdown is a lot better than no deal at all. What markets hate most is UNCERTAINTY.

The first half slowdown will mean that the U.S. will make limited progress in reducing unemployment in 2013 - which if you remember will mean continued liquidity by Federal Reserve for a prolonged period as it will take sometime to whittle down the unemployment rate.
There were also encouraging signs from China as data showed its manufacturing activity expanding last month for the third straight month. The purchasing managers' index (PMI) remained steady at 50.6 in December, although it was slightly lower than HSBC bank's PMI survey of 51.5 - a 19-month high. The lift in manufacturing appeared to have been reflected in rising commodity prices over the past few weeks, adding to suggestions the worst could be over for the global economy.

In another boost for financial markets, China's President, Hu Jintao, said in a New Year's Eve address that the country would work towards fostering global economic growth. The country would "step up efforts to promote strong, sustainable and balanced growth in the world economy", said Mr Hu, who is set to step down as president in March.
News that the North Korean leader, Kim Jong-un, had called for a "radical turnabout" in his country's economy and offered an olive branch to South Korea would also lift the market. In a rare new year's address broadcast on state television, Mr Kim said 2013 would be a year of "great creations and changes in which a radical turnabout will be effected" and that ''the building of an economic giant is the most important task'' facing North Korea.

"An important issue in putting an end to the division of the country and achieving its reunification is to remove confrontation between the North and the South," he added.

Very Interesting Economic Research - The Trilemma!

The title of the post seemed so unlikely. How can economic research be categorised as interesting? The working paper is entitled: SURFING THE WAVES OF GLOBALIZATION: ASIA AND FINANCIAL GLOBALIZATION IN THE CONTEXT OF THE TRILEMMA by Joshua Aizenman, Menzie D. Chinn and Hiro Ito. The hypothesis states that a country may simultaneously choose any two, but not all, of the following three goals: monetary independence, exchange rate stability, and financial integration.

JJ mag 132 by ❤Andrea❤.

This concept, if valid, is supposed to constrain policy makers by forcing them to choose only two out of the three policy choices. Given that Asian emerging market economies have collectively outperformed other developing economies in terms of output growth stability, it is possible that their international macro-policy management, determined within the constraint of the trilemma, has contributed to preparing these economies for higher output vulnerability possiblyexacerbated by recent globalization.

If the Asian economies do show robust and sustainable recovery while the advanced economies do not, that would have two implications. First, robust recovery is evidence for the Asian economies “decoupling” from the advanced economies. Second, it suggests that the Asian economies, most of which are quite open to international trade in goods and financial assets, are better prepared to cope with economic crises in a highly globalized environment.

History has shown that different international financial systems have attempted to achieve combinations of two out of the three policy goals, such as the Gold Standard system-guaranteeing capital mobility and exchange rate stability and the Bretton Woods system providing monetary autonomy and exchange rate stability. The fact that economies have altered the combinations as a reaction to crises or major economic events may be taken to imply that each of the three policy options is a mixed bag of both merits and demerits for managing
macroeconomic conditions.



Greater monetary independence could allow policy makers to stabilize the economy through monetary policy without being subject to other economies’ macroeconomic management, thus potentially leading to stable and sustainable economic growth. However, in a world with price and wage rigidities, policy makers could also manipulate output movement (at least in the short-run), thus leading to increasing output and inflation volatility. Furthermore, monetary authorities could also abuse their autonomy to monetize fiscal debt, and therefore end up destabilizing the economy through high and volatile inflation.

Exchange rate stability could bring out price stability by providing an anchor, and lower risk premium by mitigating uncertainty, thereby fostering investment and international trade. Also, at the time of an economic crisis, maintaining a pegged exchange rate could increase the credibility of policy makers and thereby contribute to stabilizing output movement. However, greater levels of exchange rate stability could also rid policy makers of a policy choice of using exchange rate as a tool to absorb external shocks. Prasad (2008) argues that exchange rate rigidities would prevent policy makers from implementing appropriate policies consistent with macroeconomic reality, implying that they would be prone to cause asset boom and bust by overheating the economy. Hence, the rigidity caused by exchange rate stability could not only enhance output volatility, but also cause misallocation of resources and unbalanced, unsustainable growth.

Meisa Kuroki by snowboy18.

Financial liberalization is perhaps the most contentious and hotly debated policy among the three policy choices of the trilemma. On one hand more open financial markets could lead to economic growth by paving the way for more efficient resource allocation, mitigating information asymmetry, enhancing and/or supplementing domestic savings, and helping transfer of technological or managerial know-how (i.e., growth in total factor productivity).

Also, economies with greater access to international capital markets should be better able to stabilize themselves through risk sharing and portfolio diversification. On the other hand, it is also true that financial liberalization has often been blamed for economic instability, especially over the last two decades, including the current crisis. Based on this view, financial openness could expose economies to volatile cross-border capital flows resulting in sudden stops or reversal of capital flows, thereby making economies vulnerable to boom-bust cycles.

Thus, theory tells us that each one of the three trilemma policy choices can be a double-edged sword, which should explain the wide and mixed variety of empirical findings on each of the three policy choices.

Furthermore, to make the matter more complicated, while there are three ways of pairing two out of the three policies , the effect of each policy choice can differ depending on what the other policy choice it is paired with. Hence, it maybe worthwhile to empirically analyze the three types of policy combinations in a comprehensive and systematic manner.developing economies may have been trying to cling to moderate levels of both monetary independence and financial openness while maintaining higher levels of exchange rate stability. In other words, they have been leaning against the trilemma over a period that interestingly coincides with the time when some of these economies began accumulating sizable international reserves (IR), potentially to buffer the trade-off arising from the trilemma.

None of these observations is applicable to non-emerging developing market economies. For this group of economies, exchange rate stability has been the most aggressively pursued policy throughout the period. In contrast to the experience of the emerging market economies, financial liberalization has not been proceeding rapidly for the non-emerging market developing economies.The additional dimension is the role of IR holding. Since the Asian crisis of 1997-98, developing economies, especially those in East Asia and the Middle East, have been rapidly increasing the amount of IR holding.

China, the world’s largest holder of international reserves, currently holds about $2 trillion of reserves, accounting for 30% of the world’s total. As of the end of 2008, the top 10 IR holders are all developing economies, with the sole exception of Japan. The nine developing economies, including China, Republic of Korea (Korea), Russian Federation, and Taiwan, hold about 50% of world IR. Against this backdrop, it has been argued that one of the main reasons for the rapid IR accumulation is economies’ desire to stabilize exchange rate movement.

According to one perspective, economies accumulate massive IR to achieve a target combination of exchange rate stability, monetary policy autonomy, and financial openness only a handful of economies have achieved combinations of ERS (exchange rate stability) and IR that significantly reduce output volatility. Such economies include Botswana, China, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Jordan, and Singapore. However, the fact that three Asian economies are among the economies with large IR holding and great ERS may explain why Asian economies are often perceived to be currency manipulators although they are more of exceptions than the rule.if policy makers put greater weight on real exchange rate stability, it is better to pursue more exchange rate stability and greater financial openness (which implies lower levels of monetary independence), which could have a volatility-enhancing impact on investment and output, though the answer depends on the level of IR holding.

Due to that we have not seen the deluge of hot money frolicking in these markets over the past 10 years, the greater good or the lesser evil. One interesting outlier is China; its level of monetary independence is so high that it contributes positively to higher investment volatility despite having a combination of very high IR and ERS. Despite the high volatility-increasing impact of the trilemma configuration on investment, the volatility-reducing effect on the real exchange rate seems to be outweighing the former and contributing to lower output volatility although relatively it is not such an open economy.

Why I Like TAS Offshore


I like the fact that the company recently had its IPO. I like the fact that the price went down below IPO as that shows no collusion, just allowing the fringe players to sell if they want to. The IPO was at 90 sen, now its hovering at 77-78 sen. I like the buying build up in volume. Is there something wrong with the company? Doesn't look like it at all. In fact, the more I look at it the better it gets.

Its even on a more solid standing than its older listed peers like Sealink and Coastal.
TAS Offshore Berhad (TAS) is involved in shipbuilding and ship repairing of vessels to the oil and gas players. TAS’s shipyards located in Sibu, Sarawak have the capacity to manufacture up to 23 vessels per annum. TAS intends to establish a new shipbuilding yard covering an area of at least 60 acres to cater for future growth. Typically construction period for a vessel range between six to eighteen months, depending on the type and specification.

However, due to the booming offshore support vessels activities, the construction period could stretch longer due to limited
availability of engines. Based on TAS IPO prospectus, the group intend to move up the value chain from largely building vessels to owning and chartering offshore vessels. Apart from being a vessel owner, TAS has commenced its build, own and sale operations. Based on TAS IPO prospectus there are 6 vessels built under this concept. Theoretically, margins expansion arises in an upcycle as TAS’s raw material like steel and engines are locked in at today’s cost, while vessels are sold at tomorrow’s prices.

Datuk Lau Nai Hoh, the founder and the managing director of TAS Offshore, is also the largest shareholder of the group, with a stake of approximately 50.3% post-IPO. With about 20 years of experience in the marine industry, Datuk Lau has been instrumental in the development of
TAS Offshore and is primarily responsible for the company’s planning and development of its strategic business direction. Its Non-Executive Chairman, Datu Haji Mohamed Sepuan Bin Anu, was the Agriculture Adviser in the Ministry of Modernisation of Agriculture up to April 2007.

Over the past 3 years, the Group has been growing at an impressive CAGR of 32.8%, and a bottom line growth of 43%. Its revenue, which is mainly derived from shipbuilding, has grown significantly mainly due to the Group’s endeavours to develop markets overseas. The Group has been able to secure orders from local customers, particularly from East Malaysia.
Its currently running at just 7x FY09 earnings, a slight discount to Sealink and Coastal, which is really unjustified. Considering that TAS Offshore will be in a net cash position post-IPO whereas its peers are in net debt. It has a strong order book and is an established name. The recovery in oil and gas industry bodes well for the company.

Net Profit: 7.8m (06) / 14.7m (07) / 16.0m (08) / estd 20.om (09)


Issued Shares: 180m


I see no reason why it should not trade between RM1.05-RM1.10 as a fairer value range.


p/s photos: Meisa Kuroki

China's Growth Story Too Dependent On Easy Credit?



Just how dependent is the China growth over the last 6 months on the easy credit conditions? This blog has been harping on the liquidity trap that is almost inevitable. The flip side is that the markets in China and HK will continue to benefit as Beijing would continue to "allow and encourage" more state firms to list in Shanghai and/or do a H-share listing - both very effective ways to drain some of the liquidity from the system, or at least keep it within a sphere where it could be 'controlled' somewhat.

Bank lending surged in H1 2009 to RMB7.37 trillion (US$1.08 trillion), more than three times higher than H1 2008. The figure, totaling 25% of China's annual GDP in 2008, is 47% higher than the government's RMB5 trillion target for 2009. There is significant monthly variation, however. Available data suggests that lending slowed in July 2009 even more than in April and May 2009, but June loans surged to RMB1.53 trillion (US$224 billion), a return to Q1 levels. New loans could surpass the revised RMB10 trillion benchmark for 2009. The scale of loan extension has sparked sustainability concerns, raised the risk of non-performing loans (NPLs) and helped to fuel asset-price inflation (property and equities). However, concerns that the government might rein in loans contributed to a weakening of equity markets in early August.

    Will Lending Growth Continue?

  • Banks lent RMB1.53 trillion (US$224 billion) in June, more than double the RMB664.5 billion extended in May, sparking concerns that tightening may follow. M2 rose 28.5% in June, and outstanding loans were up 34.4% y/y in June (both record highs). The central bank may have already started to tighten, selling more bonds to soak up some of the liquidity.
  • The reported lending figures from China's largest banks suggest that July's new lending should total around RMB400 billion (US$58.6 billion). Many of the commercial bills from earlier in the year will be refinanced in July through September, reducing new lending. Still, credit availability will likely remain relatively loose.
  • The big four banks reportedly cut lending to RMB168 billion (US$24.6 billion) in July from RMB497 billion (US$72.7 billion) in June, though smaller banks have increased their share of lending in recent months from about half to two-thirds. As a result, lending may not have slowed as much as some estimate.
  • If state-owned banks contributed one third of July new bank lending, like they did in Q2, then the July figure should come in around RMB500 billion (US$73.2 billion). Though if the trend of smaller commercial banks contributing a greater share continues, the actual figure could be higher.
  • The narrowing spread between M1 (18.7% y/y in May, up from 17.5% in April) and M2 (25.7% y/y in May, down from 26% in April) suggests that economic growth is gaining momentum as corporations are increasingly confident and willing to embark on future investments.
  • Loan growth shifted toward medium- and long-term loans in Q2. Commercial bills accounted for 21% in April, down from 32% in Q1, while other short-term loans declined by nearly RMB80 billion. Deposits again outpaced loans, reducing the loan-deposit ratio, which should marginally ease fears of bad debts, as firms are storing liquidity.
  • Even if loan growth slows, the net increase in loans might be around RMB8-8.5 trillion, 26-28% above 2008 for loans outstanding.
  • Factors Behind Lending Expansion

  • The People's Bank of China (PBoC) is unlikely to tighten monetary policy because the central bank is not accountable for regulating bank risk. Bank lending is playing an important role in the fiscal stimulus, and the central bank may plan to pump in money to fill holes in banks’ balance sheets from bad loans.
  • The Banking Regulatory Committee is raising minimum capital adequacy requirements from 8% in 2008 to 12% by 2010, but the PBoC controls the reserve requirements, blunting the regulators’ ability to control loan growth.
  • The China Banking Regulatory Commission may rule that subordinated debt held by another bank will no longer qualify as supplementary capital. Estimates suggest that as much as 51% of subordinated debt issued by banks (RMB210.0 billion in H1 2009, three times last year's total level) is held by other banks, which could lead banks to curtail new lending. That would be an easier path to better capital-adequacy ratios than finding buyers for the debt outside of the financial sector.
  • The China Banking Regulatory Commission suggested that a concentration of credit in some industries and businesses may pose a threat to the financial system. Banks should rely more on syndication to share the risks from new lending, the secretary of the commission said.
  • Loan growth is driven by monetary policy that encourages banks to expand loan portfolios. Banks make up for lower loan margins with expanded loan volumes and an assumption that stimulus-related credit losses will be covered by the central and/or local government. The increase in corporate loan portfolios and credit expansion may threaten the medium-term outlook for Chinese banks.
  • Michael Pettis, Peking University: "Tighter monetary policy may be necessary to contain future inflationary pressures, but the unclear economic outlook and political priority of growth make this unlikely."
  • Wu Xiaoling, PBoC Deputy Governor: The government's moral persuasion is declining. Banks should diversify, but not lend excessively in search of sustainable profits.
  • Loan curbs postponed investment in H2 2006, while loans and investment reaccelerated in Q1 2007.
  • Risks from Lending Growth

  • The efficiency of new loans is in doubt, as the economy does not have the capacity to turn these new loans into real activity. Potential tightening policies would further challenge the financing of small and medium sized enterprises.
  • NPLs may not reach 1990s levels, as most of the current round of lending has gone to local-government-backed projects rather than unprofitable state-owned enterprises. Also, because Chinese banks are more dependent on deposits than wholesale markets for funding and China's capital account remains closed, there is little risk of a financial crisis.
  • As much as 20% of the bank loans in the first five months of 2009 (US$170 billion) was invested in the stock market, while another 30% may have been used for discounted bill financing.
  • China's National Audit Office found that six Chinese banks in 2008 had extended more than US$4.39 billion worth of irregular loans, an indication of inadequate management at some of the banks' local branches. The issues included improper land purchases, fraudulent mortgages and loans to non-qualifying property developers and non-approved mortgages.

p/s photos: Meisa Kuroki

Can Asian Markets Continue To Outperform The Rest - Revisited


Asian equity markets have outperformed mature markets in 2009 thanks to continuous foreign institutional investor (FII) inflows amid diminishing risk-aversion among global investors and some signs of green shoots in Asia. As of July 8 2009, MSCI Asia Pacific gained 11.6% ytd with China and Sri Lanka as the best performers, and Australia and New Zealand as the worst performers. Despite impressive improvements, downside risks remain due to bleak corporate earnings outlook, worries over the real economy and revival of any global risk aversion.

Trends
# 2009 MSCI Asia Pacific performance in USD terms: 11.6% ytd as of July 8, up 38.7% during March 2-July 8
# 2009 MSCI Asia performance in USD terms: 11.3% ytd as of July 8, up 38.0% during March 2-July 8
# 2009 MSCI Asia (ex Japan) performance in USD terms: 29.8% ytd as of July 8, up 57.1% during March 2-July 8
# Best performers (ytd as of July 8, 2009): China: 71.5% | Sri Lanka: 56.2% | Indonesia: 53.8% | Taiwan: 47.0% | India: 42.6% | Viet Nam: 41.4%
# Worst performers (ytd as of July 8, 2009): the Philippines: 30.1% | Singapore: 31.0% | Thailand: 29.3% | South Korea: 27.3% | Pakistan: 26.7% | Hong Kong: 23.7% | Malaysia: 21.6% | Japan: 4.9% | Australia: 1.1% | New Zealand: 1.0%
# In 2009: Asia's equity market (ex Japan) have outperformed mature markets, up 29.8% ytd as of July 8 2009, while the S&P 500 Index and the U.S. Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 5.6% and 9.5% respectively during the same period. Continuous FII inflows to Asian equity markets have taken net flows to a positive US$14.4 billion as of June 24 2009, significantly up from US$10.8 billion in H1 and US$9.6 billion in H2 2008.
# Since March 2009, Asian equity markets have witnessed a rally following a surge in U.S. markets and began to benefit from the widening valuation gap on the back of relatively resilient macroeconomic fundamentals. During the March 2- July 8 period, MSCI Asia (ex Japan) rose by 57.1%, significantly higher than the S&P 500 Index and the Dow Jones Industrial Average which gained 25.5% and 20.9% respectively.
# Valuations: Taiwanese shares are the most expensive in the region, 64.6 times reported earnings, followed by New Zealand (38.0x), China (33.1x for A-shares) and South Korea (32.1x). On the other hand, Singapore (12.1x) and Pakistan (9.7x) are cheapest when compared to their regional peers.
# 2008 Review: The peak-to-trough decline in Asian equities in 2008 (more than 70% for some markets) surpassed the 60% fall in local currency terms during the 1998 Asian financial crisis. Sustained outflows from offshore Asian funds took total net redemptions in Jan-Oct 2008 to a record high such that all money that flowed in during 2007 flowed out.
# Market Integration: There is a noticeable upward trend in the Asia-U.S. correlation with the correlation parameter picking up sharply in H2 2008 (peaking during mid-Oct 2008). However, average correlations for emerging Asian equity markets are generally higher between the region's markets than with U.S. markets.
# Government intervention: Several countries including Taiwan, Pakistan, Vietnam, Thailand intervened in the stock market by narrowing the trading band, introducing stabilization fund to contain volatility, banning short-selling, directing government funds to buy share.

Outlook
# Upsides: AXJ region is now attractively valued, and buying into most of the region's equity markets seems a better bet than bonds amid increasing bond issuance. Also, as of end April 2009, market capitalization of Asian Pacific markets ($10.2tn) has come ahead of that of European markets ($9.3tn, including Africa and the Middle East) as Asian stock prices sour at a faster pace than European ones.
# Downsides: Goomy earnings forecasts, worries over the U.S. economy, exit by local investors and also FIIs alarmed at greater than expected impact of global slowdown on Asia's growth, exports, fiscal deficits, slowing consumer spending and investment may have negative impacts. Investors may move money to bond markets from equity markets in an anticipation of slower global economy's recovery due to the spread of swine flu. High (external) debt exposure of corporate sector in some countries and risks of real estate correction and bank profitability are additional risks.
# Given decreasing inflationary pressures and relatively healthy fiscal positions, further fiscal and monetary stimulus policies by Asian governments will able to boost the region's equity markets in H2 2009.
# Prospects for further inflows into Asian equities remain substantial, as global portfolio continue to adjust from relatively underweight positions, and given cheap equity valuations relative to bonds.
# Asian stocks have yet to reflect expectations for a powerful, synchronized recovery in the global economy as markets are still bearish on global growth and on emerging markets growth.
# Markets would likely grind higher first, before dropping by 20-30%: Catalysts for a correction are (1) flattening improvements in second derivatives; (2) softer than expected data coming out of China and; (3) a US% rally, which takes liquidity out of Asia ex.
# The recent rally in Asian equity markets might not continue due to still-weak real economic condition in many countries and the region's ultimate reliance on exports to the U.S. and EU, which means that financial-investor sentiment will remain susceptible to economic setbacks in those markets.


p/s photos: Meisa Kuroki

Further Clarifications On IOI Corp


Gamelion said...

I dont understand why all the bad news can be contained in one shot only & expect good news in future (nobody will be able to predict the future)???
Even if the company has sold 80% of its sales forward there is no guarantee that its customers will not be defaulting on their contracts if the CPO price may plunge in future .

Gamelion, Thats a good point. I don't know what to say to that. You are right, I am not so right.

solomon said...

Like Cramer, I prefer a micro view on IOI.

The only thing catch my eyes are the lower FFB production. Will this trend continue, could it still have revenue growth at the plantation sector for the next few quarters?

I am also of concerned with the contract default, I don't know how serious is this? Can this be absorbed by the downstream activities?

Longer term, other continents are on the rise in growing palm oil. Should they succeed, could this threaten the company financials?

There had been defaults for sure, and every time when prices plunge, there are bound to be defaults, because the situation "allows" them to default. IOI has stated that it has required smaller buyers now to put up bankers guarantee. The company will lose some business because of that because smaller sellers may not require that. Sometimes companies can only operate alongside what the majority are doing, if not, they risk losing business. In CPO, you can have the edge in production and yield management, but after it becomes a finished product, its a commodity, your palm oil is no different from those bought from a competitor. Hence if you put up "safeguards", it will affect your business. Lower production may have to do with better yield management in light of weaker prices. You can delay "harvesting" somewhat and manage your plantations to some degree. Hence lower production should not be a major cause for concern.

There will always be new competitors. Its the same for all commodities. When oil prices shoot up, there are plenty of new drilling and exploration, and even new technologies being used. We have to be clear that palm oil is still much cheaper than most alternatives, and still being unfairly painted as it is certainly a healthier alternative to most substitutes. We also have to know that it need temperate climate, and we are really do not have vast tracts of land left. You need a huge land base to have strong economies of scale, what you don't want is many small plantations scattered everywhere. In many areas, oil palm favours large players and established players with upstream and downstream businesses.


sam chong said...

If currency other than RM and Euro is used in the inter-co sales and purchases, by right one party's loss is another party's gain, so the group should be neutral. Combining the plantation and the resource-based, the margin dropped from 16% to 12 at a time when the CPO price realised was higher than last year 2900 vs 2700. ??


Currency losses can never be avoided, they can only be mitigated. IOI's losses is a concern as it speaks volumes on their hedging activity, registering those losses as a percentage of revenue basically implies that management takes a certain view on certain currencies. Investors do not want that. Investors want to buy a CPO producer and a good one at that, currency management expertise is not part of the deal. IOI management should eliminate that from their management purview.


p/s photo: Meisa Kuroki

New Stock Picks For A Nice Trade


I have been pretty careful and cautious on putting up stocks that I like, even though I think there are a bit more legs to this rally. I would like to bring your attention to the recent posting on Asset Class Returns to get an idea on the next hot sector to guide and lead the markets. Yes, its commodities. I commented: "What is more interesting is the very flat performance of commodities. The bottoming of markets may tie in with a working down of inventories in commodities. I expect commodities to outperform the other asset classes in the coming months." I expect a swift 20% trade from these:

SAAG long up to 0.29

Sapuracrest long up to 1.24

IOI Corp long up to 4.50

Kulim-WB long up to 3.32
Kulim long up to 6.00




p/s photo: Meisa Kuroki


Brilliant Bank - A Fairytale With A Conflict Of Interest?


Once upon a time there was a successful bank called Brilliant Bank. It grew more than 10% every year for the past 20 years and then successfully ventured into fund management. Brilliant Bank had the best return on capital, best return on assets, the lowest NPLs and the highest capital adequacy ratio among all other banks in the country. Heck, it even compares very well with other banks in the region.

Thanks to their steady and careful management culture, their fund management business also witnessed similar growth patterns as the bank. The fund management unit is 100% owned by the bank. Funds under management grew exponentially. After a few years they have about 20 pure equity or equity linked funds. The total funds under management for equities may well be around RM10bn. The total market cap for the bank is around RM20bn.

The unique thing is that in almost every single fund, Brilliant Bank shares will almost always be one of their top 3 holdings. Fair enough that Brilliant Bank has performed exceedingly well over the long term, and that in turn has helped many of the funds to outperform their respective indices. But surely everyone can see that this has to be a gray area when you want to talk of things like transparency, conflict of interest areas, corporate integrity issues, etc.

So much so that the amount of shares held by the "funds" in Brilliant Bank may reach 5%-10% of free float of the bank. Decisions are made by fund managers, working in a fund management unit 100% owned by Brilliant Bank. Really, nobody sees any conflict of interest here??!!

Anyway, in this fictional story, nobody complained because Brilliant Bank performed well, and hence the funds also performed well. There will come a time, if and when Brilliant Bank digs a hole in some financial exposure, and say loses 70% in value over a short period of time. Can we expect the unit holders of the funds to start complaining then? If that happens, what will be the repercussions if the funds were to buy even more shares in Brilliant Bank.

When is buying substantive shares considered as "supporting the share price", and when it is not? If the action is done by one party, that is easy to gather evidence, but what if the buying is by 20 funds? When can we say there is collusion, and when there is no collusion.

I am just writing a fictional story (gulp), but maybe certain things are even more obvious in reality than in fiction. In order to prevent this fictional story from becoming a non-fiction tragedy, I would like the Securities Commission to look closer to the following rules or conventions:

a) do we have a clear guideline when a majority owned fund management unit buys shares in related companies; there must be guideline on percentage of funds' exposure and even minimum time line in holding the shares; there must be safeguards that minority shareholders will not be disadvantaged by the timing of the trades that these funds enter into

b) there must be utmost transparency in how much shares, at what price, and when were the shares acquired and disposed to all unit holders

In the meantime, Brilliant Bank continues on its merry ways by producing good results and getting liquidity mopped up by the ever growing fund management unit. You scratch my back, I scratch your back... but hey, your back is my back!!

p/s photos: Meisa Kuroki



Maybank's Not-So-Right Rights Issue!


I can understand the left hand right hand rights issue by TMI, supported by Khazanah, following the big cash giveaway by Telekom Malaysia. That was a preconceived strategy when the company was split up. The Maybank rights issue is altogether different. As reported by Finance Asia with my comments in purple.

Finance Asia: Investors reacted negatively to the RM6 billion ($1.6 billion) rights issue announced by Malayan Banking, or Maybank, after the close on Friday

The renounceable rights issue had been well-flagged in the local media and on the wires, and thus the sell-off was most likely not due to the pending dilution, which could be as much as 45%. The Malaysian lender's earnings report for the six months to December 2008, which was also released on Friday, may however have sparked a realisation that its capital-raising exercise may not be quite as pre-emptive as for some of its Singapore peers, such as DBS.

Its capital ratios may look okay for now, but analysts take a cautious view in light of the difficult economic environment -- second finance minister Nor Mohamed Yacop said on Friday that the government isn't sure whether Malaysia will be able to escape a recession -- as well as Maybank's aggressive overseas expansion. (Duh! Only government departments and officials touted the "we may not be going into a recession, we might be able to avert it even"... if they bothered to check not-the mainstream media, its foregone conclusion months ago. People, its ok to go into recession, even the man on the street is ok with that, what we want to know is that our government is able to face up to it early, be transparent and candid about it, and then try to tackle it intelligently... on all counts, fail, fail, fail.. The citizens need not be lulled into a false sense of security, people are smarter nowadays, no thanks to main stream media and official pronouncements. Something is not right when many outside the government can read economic trends better!)

J.P. Morgan noted in a report that Maybank is facing a deteriorating economy and added that there is little likelihood of an "upside surprise in earnings". And Fiona Leong of AmResearch argued that "while its domestic operations remain healthy, the group's international operations are experiencing stress. Furthermore, its just-announced rights issue is highly dilutive and will cap share price performance." Both banks have a sell-equivalent recommendation on the stock.

However, Maybank itself referred to the proposed rights issue as a pre-emptive move to further optimise its capital structure and strengthen its balance sheet to enhance shareholder value. It will also "address market expectations for higher capital levels for financial institutions globally", the bank said. Bloomberg quoted representatives from the bank at a press conference on Friday as saying that the capital raised from the rights issue will be sufficient for the next three to five years and that Maybank doesn't see a need to raise more capital.

Following the rights issue, the bank's core capital ratio will increase to 11.01% from 8.13%, while its risk-weighted capital ratio will improve to 16.42% from 13.54%, based on the end-2008 results. Its gearing ratio will drop to 0.58 times from 0.77, based on the balance sheet for the fiscal year to June 2008 and adjusted for "certain material transactions". The money raised will be used for working capital and general banking purposes.

The bank, which is Malaysia's largest lender by assets, proposed to issue up to 2.212 billion rights shares on the basis of nine new shares for every 20 existing shares at a 30% to 40% discount to the theoretical ex-rights price. This is in line with DBS's $2.7 billion rights issue in January, which was offered at a 35% discount to the theoretical ex-rights price. The ongoing rights offers for Singapore developer CapitaLand and Indonesia's Bank Danamon are also offered at discounts of 35% and 34%, respectively, while CapitaMall Trust is offering its shares at a 28.7% discount to the theoretical ex-rights price.

The exact price of Maybank's offering will be determined at a later, yet to be specified, date, which will give the bank, and the arrangers, the flexibility to respond in case the market should take a sudden turn for the worse, or perhaps for the better.

Maybank's shareholders will need to approve the rights issue at an extraordinary general meeting, expected to be held in about three weeks, and representatives for the bank say they plan to complete the fund-raising by the end of April.

Existing shareholders representing 69.4% of its capital have agreed to take up their share of the offering. These include Employees Provident Fund, which holds 13.7%, Permodalan Nasional Berhad (PNB), which has a 5.9% stake, and Skim Amanah Saham Bumiputera (ASB), which is a unit of PNB and Maybank's largest shareholder with 45.6%. On top of that, PNB will apply for an excess allocation of up to 20%. (Obviously a smart move in anticipation of a possibility that the rights might be under subscribed. Getting PNB in for excess allocation is smart, so that the rights issue wouldn't turn into a fiasco).

According to Maybank, the remaining 10.6% will be underwritten by other parties, which haven't yet been determined. However, it is expected that Credit Suisse and Goldman Sachs, which are the international advisers for the rights issue, will play a role. Maybank-IB is a principal adviser for the issue.

Maybank reported a net profit of M$735 million for the second quarter of fiscal 2009, which ends on June 20 this year - a 28.4% improvement from the first quarter. The profit in the first half to December 2008 declined 10.9% from the same period a year earlier to M$1.3 billion, primarily due to a 27% increase in overhead expenses and a 77% surge in loan loss provisions to M$504 million.

AmResearch noted that the gross NPLs from Maybank's international operation more than doubled to M$927 million in December 2008 from M$406.5 million six months earlier. The bank also did not take any impairment charges for the second quarter of fiscal 2009 related to its recently acquired stakes in Bank Internasional Indonesia, MCB Bank in Pakistan and An Binh Commercial Bank in Vietnam following a M$242 million impairment loss for its 20% investment in MCB in the first quarter. (This is where the crux of the matter lies, Maybank bought and invested late into regional banks, at highish prices. The crisis has basically set Maybank up to need to write down substantially on their acquisitions. NOTE THAT NO IMPAIRMENT CHARGES WERE RECORDED for the latest quarter - hint, its coming over the next couple of quarters!!!).

The Maybank management expects to complete an impairment review for its acquisitions in BII and MCB by June 2009, and AmResearch's Leong says any potential impairment losses will drag earnings lower and dent the projected book value.

"Maybank paid an average of 4.3 times price-to-book for its 97.2% stake in BII and 5.2 times for the 20% equity interest in MCB. Our calculations suggest that should Maybank write down these investments to 3.5 times price-to-book, there would be an impairment charge of M$1.258 billion for BII and M$892 million for MCB. The total impairment charge of M$2.15 billion would be 80% of our revised core net profit of M$2,687 billion for fiscal 2009," she said.

Rights issues are without question the capital raising method of choice in Asia this year, with 29 deals worth a combined $2.5 billion completed so far, according to Dealogic, which doesn't include the portion of the rights offer taken up by the controlling shareholder in its calculations. This is the highest year-to-date volume in the region ever and follows a record year for rights offers in 2008 when $15.2 billion was raised from 155 deals.

Traditionally not that popular with major companies in Asia, rights issues have moved to the forefront as investors remain cautious about taking on new exposures, making it almost impossible for companies to raise equity through new share placements - especially in larger sizes above $1 billion.

Maybank's offering will run almost parallel to a rights offering by Malaysian mobile operator TM International, which last Thursday announced plans to raise M$5.25 billion ($1.4 billion) over the next couple of months. The TMI deal has strong support from its largest shareholder, Khazanah Nasional, which has committed to buy up to 65% of the deal, if necessary.

Final thoughts, sell first ask questions later. The rights will be an uphill exercise. If you still want to buy Maybank, look for when the rights are traded, they could be "very cheap". Even when you get the rights cheaply, remember you will have to tolerate a few quarters where there will be substantial writedowns on the regional banks' acquisitions.

p/s photo: Meisa Kuroki